Moving in together?
by Dr. Leah
Filed under Single Dads, Single Moms, Single Parents, Tips & Advice
A single mom whom we adore has contacted us for some help. She asked if we’d post her current dilemma here — anonymously — and we gladly agreed.
So, here’s her situation:
“I’ve been dating an amazing guy for more than a year and we’re talking about taking the next step: moving in together!
Here’s the deal: I have two kids. He has none. My daughters adore him, and vice-versa. We’ve talked about getting married someday. He’d love to have a child of his own, and I’m very open to this, too.
We’ve discussed all the practical logistics, such as finding a home in the same school district for the kids’ sakes, sharing daily chores, budgeting for household expenses, and our bank accounts. (I’m paying off my credit card debt and finishing college.)
He’s an incredible support when it comes to being both a partner and a potential co-parent. As you can imagine, I’m exhausted most of the time and I hope that moving in together will make things easier.
So, what’s the problem?
Well, how do I know I’m making the right decision? My kids are my No. 1 priority — and the last thing I want to do is drag them through another break-up.
Moving in together feels right — but how do I know for sure?”
~~
Like all of us, this mom has had her share of relationship blunders. So, we’d love to hear your thoughts on this one:
How do you know when moving in together is right?
Is there anything else this couple should talk about before making a final decision?
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
Related posts:
- My ex-wife is moving away. Advice? We’re always so honored to hear from fathers at Singlemommyhood! Recently one of our longtime readers, Steve, reached out to...
- Do you need to move? Rachel at Single Mom Seeking has been writing about moving to a new home. While her daughter is handling the...
- When Dad talks to his daughter about her period The dads who comment at Singlemommyhood continue to amaze us. You’re so present and genuine. And add so much to...
- How to marry the wrong guy Seventeen years ago, Anne Milford called off her first wedding. In the aftermath of the breakup, she discovered something shocking:...


Follow Singlemommyhood on Twitter



Twitter @ http://www.solomother.com
My wonderful man asked me and my son to move in with him. I said no.
This is the guy I want to spend forever with, and still I said no.
Now, I know marriage isn’t a guarantee… but I will not put my son in a position to lose another man he loves, and if we move in together and something goes wrong, it’s just that much easier to walk away.
I wish we were living together right now. I wish we were sharing the day to day stuff. It makes me sad and annoyed that we’re not.
But really, if we’re ready to move in together, then why don’t we get married, instead? I think that’s the question she has to ask herself. If the two of them are ready to move in together, but not for marriage, she has to know why.
Solomother’s last blog post..Guilty
Twitter @ http://www.singlemommindy.blogspot.com
I agree with Solomother. When you have kids the moving in together thing only seems right with a ring on your finger. But even then there are no guarantees.
MindyMom’s last blog post..Well That Was Interesting
Twitter @ http://www.singleparenttravel.net
I will chime in with the old fashioned set. Are you endorsing moving in with a guy and are you willing to encourage your daughter to do so when she is 18?
Your kids already have a relationship with this guy–so a break up will be tough on them in any event–living together or not.
From my POV, I need to concentrate on my kids and bringing them up to be as moral, responsible, ethical, as I can. To me, part of that is exposing them to loving relationships, but not necessarily living together. Any of my girlfriends need to know that till my kids are 18, they are #1 and she (unfortunately) will be a distant 4th place also ran.
I dated a woman once that was wanting more sleepover time at her house and I was just not comfortable with it and we broke up. What message does it send to her 17 year old son when his mom’s boyfriend is “shacking up” with them. Does her 15 year old daughter really want to see my fat middle aged self in the mornings?
Childhood, in the scope of things, is a fleeting moment. I vote to savor it and enjoy it and continue to put the kids first, and to be honest if the guy is worth keeping, he will understand and he will stick around.
John F’s last blog post..For The 40+ Generation
Twitter @ http://lovebabz.blogspot.com
No one is living with me unless we are married. I have 4 children 2 sons and 2 daughters. I do not wish to convey to them that this is a casual relationship. That somehow getting married is some terrible thing to avoid. Also, if marriage is what you want then you have to stand in your truth and ask the hard questions and be prepared for the answers.
Living with someone with the hopes of them asking you to marry them is starting off on a weak foot.
If you are afraid of scaring him off with the big talk of marriage, then what do you have anyway? This is hard stuff but each us knows what we want in our hearts and if marriage is what you want, then you should say so. But if its not what you want then living together means what then?
I would say be clear about what you want. Stand in your truth.
lovebabz’s last blog post..TRUE LOVE TUESDAY: SO FAR
I’m an old-fashioned kind-of gal, so take what I say with a grain of salt. I have always believed that moving in comes hand in hand with marriage. Not before. Of course, I always felt that babies came after marriage, too, and it didn’t quite work out that way. BUT, moving in is something I can control more easily. For me, personally, I will not move in with anyone unless it’s a result of marriage. I just don’t think I could chance opening my child up to that if things were to go south. I mean, a breakup is going to affect our kids anyway, but if you’re living together and things go south, they’re going to have to deal with and adjust to a whole lot more.
I don’t have any of the answers, and I can only answer for me personally. But moving in isn’t a risk I would take, even in the most secure of relationships. Why open myself and my son up to that?
Ashley’s last blog post..Who says bliss has to be wedded?
I’m in the 40+ generation but I’m not a huge fan of marriage. However, I also live in a state with good common law marriage statutes so not getting that piece of paper doesn’t mean you can walk away easily.
You didn’t say how old the kids are. That could make a big difference in how they perceive the situation. Little ones don’t understand that there are different stages of relationships, it is all or nothing. Teenagers get that moving in with someone may not be permanent. With or without kids, I advocate living with someone before you get married because that is the best way to determine if your management styles mesh.
I’m also wierd because I consider a long-term committed relationship to be a business relationship with emotions involved. You need to make sure your management styles for paying bills, cleaning, vehicle maintenance, etc. are compatible. Are you comfortable with waiting until the last minute and running to the grocery store and paying the phone bill hours before it is due to be cut off or do you insist on paying it as soon as it arrives? Do you spray down the shower every time you step out or just give it a scrub once every week or so? These are the types of things that can drive someone crazy and you don’t learn until you move in. I wouldn’t want to marry someone until I’d lived with them for a year, kids or no kids.
I’d say talk to your kids, if they are old enough to understand. See how they feel about it. You need to look into your own head and see if you are moving in for convenience or because you are ready for that level of committment with this person.
I just reread the original post again and wanted to add that teaching our kids how to break up with someone is as important as teaching them how to have a relationship. Odds are, they are going to do just as much breaking up as they do committing in their life. Both can be handled the right way and the wrong way. Breaking up is painful…but it is is also a fact of life. How you handle it is what is the important thing.
Also, if they see you afraid to make a committment, that could impact their future ability to make committments, too.
Our roles as parents are to teach them about life. To prepare them for what they will encounter to the best of our ability. I think that hiding behind our kids to keep from making committments that might not work out is doing both us and our kids a disservice. Our kids are watching how we handle things to learn what to do when it happens to them. If we protect them by not putting ourselves out there, they won’t learn.
Simply put, I’d tell this mom to read what SoloMother wrote. No man is living with me and my child unless we’re married. And if he wants to, I’d question why one and not the other. Kids are impressionable, and I’m not going to do something I wouldn’t want my daughter to do.
Twitter @ aprilabtbalance
I’m less old-fashioned and not that concerned about marriage, but I do think it’s great that you’ve discussed so many of the practical aspects already. Still, there’s more to go through.
LegalZoom has a marital and separation agreement that would touch on a lot of it. I also agree with the commenter who mentioned that showing our kids how to break up isn’t the worst thing in the world, either. The most important thing to me would be honest and open communication. You’re not going to agree on everything, and your kids would expect you to keep the title as main care-giver (which I doubt you’d give up, but it doesn’t hurt to state the obvious to your kids).
You have to both be open about how much he’ll deal with your kids, and how involved he’ll be in discipline, and understand that even if they seem fine with it, they will most likely test their boundaries in the new situation.
It wouldn’t hurt to meet with a marriage counselor who can help guide you through all the possible scenarios so that you both feel more confident about it. Of course, life will always throw curve balls, but if you have a Plan B, you’re more likely to get through it.
And FWIW, I also know a couple that, while they still fight about the kids, they’re still very much together and very much in love and sometimes just agree to disagree.
But if you equate commitment with a ring, then there’s nothing wrong with sticking with that – if that’s how YOU feel about it.
April’s last blog post..In Honor of Dr. George Tiller
There are many more things to consider. As a Stepfamily Coach, I can tell you that things changes after you move in together. Only YOU can know if this man is the right man for you. Even if he is, that doesn’t mean everything will go smoothly after you move in together. I don’t know how much he has been around your children or how much he has disciplined them, or even if he has seen you discipline them much. I also don’t know how old your children are or the type of relationship they have with their father. All of these things can affect your relationship with him and as a family, after your union. Just because your kids adore him now doesn’t mean they will adore him disciplining them when you all live together. Each family has different habits and ways of doing things. If your kids’ habits clash with your boyfriend’s, everybody in your house may struggle with figuring out how to adapt to each other. If you and your boyfriend truly love each other, you both can make it work. It takes a lot of effort. If you both are willing to make the effort to form a happy stepfamily, then I highly recommend you contact a Stepfamily Coach for a consultation. A Stepfamily Coach can give you realistic expectations and offer strategies for coping with each other, as well as suggestions to create less conflict, resentment, or arguments. It will be well worth your time to look one up.
I’m on the “pro” side. We’re living together, but not married & we’re in it for the long term.
I’m not a big fan of marriage any more and I certainly don’t buy into the bridal industry. I’ve made a lifelong commitment to M, the kids and M are family now – and M will always be a part of our lives even if the unlikely happens.
Maybe it’s because we were friends for so long first, I can trust him without a “contract” or obligation like marriage. I know there’s no guarantee, and I’ve accepted that.
IMHO even if my kids eventually had to say goodbye to M they would still have been better off with him in their lives for a finite amount of time than without him at all. Life is full of goodbyes of all sorts – I’d rather teach my kids to enjoy life deal with inevitable goodbyes in a healthy manner than to try to shield them from any reality and leave them with no tools for future relationships.
Momartfully’s last blog post..Hospital 2 – Family 0
Judy offers great advice but doesn’t mention whether marriage should be a factor or not. Personally I’d question why a man would want to move in but not make a full commitment. Even if you’re not “old fashioned,” you have to think about the message you’re giving your child(ren). I am open and honest with my child and plan to continue the lines of communication, but for me, this is about respect. For her, and for me. It’s definitely a personal preference.
I have two friends, both were single parents, one a single dad and the other a single mom… each with one child only. Before they even got romantically involved they saw the benefit of renting a property with two separate living units. The arrangement worked out very well, only after they saw that it was a mutual win win and very supportive arrangement for both adults and children, did they decide to get physically intimate… They intentionally resisted the urge their children’s sake! They have been now happily married, living under one roof, for the past 3 years.
I am currently seeing a man, a single dad, who I am growing to love. We’ve been spending every weekend together for the past couple months. It must have been at least a year ago, barely having known one another, when he suggested to me renting a place with two separate living spaces together.. our kids enjoy each other, we have similar parenting styles, enjoy the same activities, and it’s nice to have another adult presence around. Extra hands in the garden are nice too. We have not yet actively sought a place together, though we still entertain the idea.
Though we are no more than close friends that see promising relationship potential at this point, and we have talked about sex to the point where it can drive us crazy, we are both very cautious of confusing a good friendship with premature sex.
The other night over dinner I asked my friend, (the once single dad now happily maried) if he has any suggestions… He told me to wait at minimum six month before sleeping with him, then if it doesn’t work out, no hard feelings and the friendship remains. Other friends tell me otherwise.
For those of us who have been through the ringer with relationships, I can only hope that we have become wiser and clearer in ourselves and what we really want. That we have become more discerning, and have learned to understand what is going on inside and the reasons for making the decisions we choose to make.
Twitter @ /
Limor, it’s so great to hear from you! Thanks so much for the update on what’s going on — and I’m blown away by your patience.
Twitter @ /
@Chai Girl, We find your comment incredibly poignant:
“… teaching our kids how to break up with someone is as important as teaching them how to have a relationship. Odds are, they are going to do just as much breaking up as they do committing in their life. Both can be handled the right way and the wrong way. Breaking up is painful…but it is is also a fact of life. How you handle it is what is the important thing.”
It’s true: no one wants to get divorce, break up, or go separate ways. But sometimes we do move on, and teaching our children how to cope with change is very important. Thank you.
Twitter @ martinimom
I’m not a traditional girl, so the idea of moving in together before marriage is perfectly acceptable. Preferable, even. And I absolutely agree with @Chai Girl who says that teaching our children how to break up is also important. But the marriage vs. moving in together conversation has been pretty well covered here, so moving on…
As the child of divorced parents (from the age of 2), I lived through my fair share of live-in boyfriends and girlfriends. Both of my parents got remarried (and re-divorced) and both had other live-in relationships over the course of my upbringing. I am still in contact with almost ALL of those people. The break ups did not end my relationship with them.
My boyfriend and I are also on the precipice of moving in together. I have a son, he has two daughters. In our discussions of logistics and parental roles, etc., we’ve also discussed what our relationships with each other’s children will look like, should we break up. My opinion (and he agrees, thankfully!) is that if he’s moving in with me, he’s moving in with us; if he’s committing to me; he’s committing to us. If he and I break up, that does not mean that his relationship with my son is over.
I understand that this wouldn’t work in every situation. And certainly, from my own experience, there were some of my parents’ exes that I wanted nothing more to do with. But those were the exception, not the rule. My parents were open to – and encouraged – continued relationships where appropriate, and I wanted to make sure my man was open to the same thing; that he was really committing to playing a parental role to my son (and me to his daughters).
Depending on where you land on the traditional scale, this may sound absolutely crazy to you. Admittedly, I have one heck of an extended family. But they are all very important figures in my life, and I’m glad my parents lived with each of them… even if it didn’t work out with any of them in the end.
IMHO, if you’ve thought this through (sounds like you have) and it makes sense logically AND your gut is telling you it’s right – your heart and mind in agreement, in other words – then you’re off to a great start!
I don’t understand couples who play house without getting married. If you have no kids, then sure, move in together and screw your brains out. Who cares. But to have kids and co-habitate just seems like you’re making a mockery of the sanctity of marriage, and opening yourself up for a world of hurt and confusion for children should the relationship end. Of course kids are resilient and bounce back, but I’d rather it be from a divorce than an impulsive move because I had the hots for someone. Besides, what is he supposed to address me as? His “live in girlfriend”? No thanks. It just sounds cheesy.
I think everything changes with kids. It may seem perfect for the adults, but I would probably stand firm and not move in together unless marriage is imminent (he proposed, you said yes.) When you have kids, it gives you that much more excuse to stand firm. For now, play house by having someone watch all the kids (or when your exes have them) and spend a weekend “in” together.
I understand what other folks have said about “in case of a breakup” but I think the relationship should be pretty solid first (been together long enough so there are no major parts of eachother’s thoughts, feelings, and life have been left out).
If its “no big deal” for the grandparents and parents to have had live in boyfriends and girlfriends, the children may not grow up to believe that marriage is special or sacred. Sure things happen, some people get divorced. But why not let the kids see your marriage (or second marriage) with you being respected, standing firm, and your husband adoring you rather than go to school not being able to explain why “Bob” (or whatever his name) lives with you.
Maybe I am a bit traditional. I am divorced with no kids, and have a wonderful boyfriend who I feel is the love of my life. But I am standing firm and we won’t move in together unless we are getting married. I did move in with my ex years before we were married – and I found the marriage that resulted quite a few years later was not as committed as a result.
Everything will change if you move in together. It may seem like he likes your kid(s),and your kid(s) may say they like him, but that doesn’t mean it’s true. Children are willing to sacrifice a lot if it means that their mom is happy, but guess what? Those children are compromising THEIR feelings, THEIR comfort, and THEIR expectations of what a mom should be. Do you want that? I cannot tell you how many times my mother’s boyfriend(s) said that they liked us, that they could adopt us….but you know what…they said that to get her into bed. They didn’t like me or my siblings, and they made no effort to hide it ONCE THEY MOVED IN. We (the kids), didn’t like them either, but we felt like we had to put up with it for mom’s sake….that’s shi**y! Parents are suppose to sacrifice for their children, not the other way around. All in all, don’t move in with him. Some day in thefuture, your kid(s) may come up to you and say..”You know what, I hated those guys who lived with us,and I can’t believe you put us through that just so you could be happy. We were unhappy.”