Do I have a Daddy?

A solo mom’s email landed in our Inbox this week, and here’s what struck us: her story is similar to ours. Her ex split town after she became a mom, and she has had no contact with him.

He has since remarried and now their daughter is almost two. This mother has tried to communicate with her ex, but it’s his new wife who has curtly emailed back. Clearly, this dad plans to stay out of the picture.

This solo mom worries: “What will I say when my daughter asks about her daddy?”

How about when other children ask your child, “Do you have a Daddy?”

We understand. These “daddy questions” are among the most perplexing faced by solo moms. (Of course, we also understand that many loving dads face the same difficult questions about an absent mom. )

Very few children question their family structure before the age of three. But in preschool, children start to notice that other families might be different from their own,  This is when kids often start to ask question about “Daddy.”

Also, both of us also remember other children coming over for play dates and curiously asking our children, “Where’s your Daddy?”

Just like all other tough questions, the “daddy questions” will pop up when you least expect it. So, it pays to get prepared:

If you shy away from answering “daddy questions” — or your children simply sense that this is a forbidden topic — they will often make up their own story.

We’ve overheard a child anxiously tell his preschool friends that his dad is fighting a war near where Santa Claus lives. And we know a little girl who fibbed to her classmates that her dad died from the “heartbreak of psoriasis” … obviously, melding an emotion expressed by her mom with an insipid television commercial (so sad!) When there’s an information void, children will fill it with bits of fantasy and overheard snatches of information.

If you’re also a solo parent, do you wonder what you’ll say when your child asks this question?

Or, maybe you’ve already been faced with this question?

What advice can you offer this solo mom whose child is still a bit young to ask about Daddy?

Should she wait for her child to open up this conversation? Or should this solo mom start this conversation now?

If so, what’s the best way to start?

~~~

(Photo courtesy of Nascity via Flickr)

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

Related posts:

  1. Can I live with Dad? “Can I live with Dad?” When solo moms in our Singlemommyhood hear this question, they often feel confused — and...
  2. Another absent parent dilemma We are grateful to The Prisoner’s Wife for our guest post today. She describes herself as “a mommy, scribe, and...
  3. When your ex suddenly appears via Facebook This weekend, we received this urgent email from a single mom who could really use your advice: Here’s what’s...
  4. Do you worry about your father-less son? When we read this recent, emotional post by Los Angeles Single Mama –“What A Boy Wants, What A Boy...

Comments

26 Responses to “Do I have a Daddy?”
  1. Twitter @ http://mommasunshine.wordpress.com
    My girls’ dad is very involved in their lives, so this isn’t a question I’ll ever have to answer. But if it were, I would approach the topic with as much honesty as was age-appropriate. I would feel no obligation to spare the absent father’s feelings – he obviously made his choice, and my only obligation would be to my child and his or her feelings.
    MommaSunshine´s last blog ..Words of Wisdom from my Six-Year-Old My ComLuv Profile

  2. Twitter @ SHSoloMama
    Oh this subject terrified me for years and years. I was so worried about how to handle the questions. I read books and books and books but they all said the same thing, don’t bad mouth the child’s father and that’s it. Don’t get me wrong, that is excellent advice. I have never, nor will I ever, bad mouth her father. Once she is old enough to understand, she will know what a piece of crap he is (thank god for websites and blogs for venting, lol).

    When the question did finally come up, I used some advice that I had gotten from a message board somewhere on my quest for the perfect answer. She wanted to know his name and where he lived. Then she asked why she never met him. I explained to her that sometimes people aren’t ready to be parents and her father wasn’t ready to be a parent so he’s not a part of our life. Then, after that seemed to sink in, I told her I was very excited to be a parent and am happy to get to have her all to myself. We giggled and I tickled her and she said “You are the best parent there is, Mommy.” A couple of years later I overheard her telling a friend that was over playing that her father lives in Maryland (we have moved to New Hampshire) and he isn’t part of our life. No big deal, it was just like she was talking about what she had for breakfast.

    There are also a couple of books that we have read together since we had the conversation. I don’t know if they helped that much but I’m sure they didn’t hurt. One is called Do I Have a Daddy? And the other is called Love is a Family. I can’t remember the authors of them but you can find them on Amazon.

    I’ve taken her to see a therapist to be sure I knew what was going on in her little head. The therapist told me that her emotional maturity was above her age group. That was an amazing feeling.
    Semi-Hippie Single Mama´s last blog ..Keep the dryer heat that you pay for, inside. My ComLuv Profile

  3. Twitter @ askingamy
    I agree with the comment above about never bad mouthing an absent dad, and also about being honest in an age-appropriate way. I dealt with this in my own life, though there was some sporadic and affectionate contact between my ex and our daughter. She seemed to understand her place in the scheme of things and able to field other kids’ questions by saying “My dad lives in New York.” (We lived in Washington).

    My daughter processed this differently at different stages of her life. I think she always knew where she stood with me and this gave her the emotional stability to cope with her losses. I also think that kids grow to understand that every family is different and that love is what binds people together. If there was absolutely no contact with a dad (my cousin has a child with a sperm donor) then the “every family is different” conversation will have real resonance.

    Even very young children can understand that some kids have mom, some kids have mom and dad, some kids live with grandma, some kids have two dads or two moms. If their primary parent is in a good place emotionally, the child will look to her for cues about how to be.

  4. Twitter @ http://farrahlynn.blogspot.com
    Wow this one is just for me….I tell my children they have no daddy.. because legally they don’t have a father. I tell them that some kids have dads and some don’t and you don’t.

    I tell them that one day, should mommy get married, then you will have a daddy, if I don’t then you won’t.

    My kids are in preschool and the question comes up and my 5 y/o son’s teacher, after my son adamantly denied not having a dad, told him you do have a dad.. I told her to stop telling him that because he does not have a dad and he may never have one.

    Yes technically they do have a man who donated his genetic material to create their existence, but since he is not or has never raised them, He is not their dad. My son’s were in foster care all of their lives….He dropped off his sperm and bounced. .Although I did not contribute my DNA to bring them to their existence I AM THEIR MOM. I am the one who raises them..I am the one who sheds the blood, sweat, and tears…..Just because you make a baby that for darn sho’ don’t make you a parent.

    My kids know they are adopted (as much as a 3 and 5 y/o can understand) and that they did not grow in my tummy and that there are other people out their that they are “related to” who brought them into this world ( again as much as a 3 and 5 y/o can understand). But until such a day that God send my husband (SEND HIM JESUS ..lol) I firmly tell them they have no dad because it’s the truth.
    Mommy to the Monsters´s last blog ..formspring.me My ComLuv Profile

  5. Twitter @ http://singlemommindy.blogspot.com
    Since birth, my daughter has seen her father only a few times a year for a couple hours at a time. The subject of who her “daddy” was never came up until she was 3 for the reasons you stated – her peers and also t.v. shows. By then she knew her father by his first name so when she started asking about her daddy I told her that he was her father. Now that she’s 4 she also comprehends that he is not like other daddies and I think she struggles with that but I follow her lead and try to honestly address her questions as they come up.
    Mindy@SingleMomSays´s last blog ..A Little Love My ComLuv Profile

  6. Dr. Leah says:

    Amy Dickinson: Obviously, you raise an excellent point. Children do take their cues from us …if we’re in a “good place”, our kids will fare much better. Thanks for joining the conversation.

  7. JT says:

    I am still scared of this very issue when my son gets into preschool and they start doing “Family” art or trees, or talk about their mommies AND daddies.

    Currently, my son is in a small nanny-share where the older kids ask me if my son has a daddy. I tell them that his daddy is sick and lives far away. My ex had some mental health issues (bipolar) and toward the end, was emotionally abusive. They still ask from time to time when we have playdates at our house.

    My son is still young, but I plan to tell him that his daddy really loves him and wants him to be happy, but is sick and needs to get better. I’m just not sure if that will open a flood gate of other questions like, “When will he get better? Can we go see him in the hospital? Can’t he take some medicine so he can see me?”

    I like what Semi-Hippie Single Mama had to say about some people aren’t ready to be parents and that he’s just not a part of our life. Good advice. Thanks.

  8. Dr. Leah says:

    JT: Thanks for sharing your experiences with us. Semi-Hippie Single Mama did offer some great advice …you want to give your kids the message that the other parent’s absence is because of the other parent’s inadequacies/difficulties …NOT because there is something “wrong” with your child.

  9. Satsuki says:

    Twitter @ satsukirebel
    I haven’t had to worry about this yet and honestly, I haven’t worried about it much at all. The “sperm donor” (as I like to think of him) has met her 3 times in her life to date, all of which were during the age of 1. He doesn’t seem to have an interest in her but I sure won’t be telling her that.

    She is MY precious daughter and that’s what matters. I’ll be going with the “all families are different” speech when the time comes. I don’t even need to bash him. I’d say it’s not my loss. My wonderful baby and I are a family and I am more than grateful for her existence.

  10. Louise says:

    My son has never asked about his father, we split when he was 2. I mean never, he has never asked about daddy, if he has one, or where he is. I think this is a bit weird, and don’t know whether to broach the subject first, or leave it until he asks. He’s very happy and well adjusted, so I’m not sure what to do.

  11. Kate says:

    Twitter @ http://katarena.typepad.com
    My son is almost 4 and this questions has come up quite a few times. His dad is not & has not ever been an active part of his life. Maybe 7 visits since he was born. He recently signed over his rights & we’ve not heard from him in almost a year. When this does come up it’s generally because the other kids at his daycare talk about doing things with their dads or he sees their dads pick them up. The approach that I use right now is to tell him that our family just has mommy & him. I tell him that there are lots of different types of families but ours is special because we have each other. Then I go on to talk about my parents (his Mimi & Papa) and my brother and how we have lots of family to love. So far this has been more than sufficient. I know that will change one day when he’s older, and depending on his age and maturity level I will adjust that answer as needed. When I feel he’s old enough I will tell him in more detail where “dad” is.

  12. Rachel Sarah says:

    Twitter @ /
    @Louise: I’ve been fascinated about this, too: my child didn’t start asking about her father until she was about nine. But beginning around age 3, almost every girl who came to our home for a play date, asked her, “Where’s your Daddy?”

  13. alley says:

    Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
    I have to admit, that I did not handle this well with my younger children. The Asshat was actually involved with the oldest when he was a baby and toddler, so the oldest has always known he has a dad that just doesn’t visit very often. The younger two, just don’t have a daddy.

    The complication is that he isn’t entirely absent. He sees them once or twice a month for a few months, then he drops out of the world, then he shows up again, with a new girlfriend and new job, very little explaination at to what he’s been up to or where he’s been, and wants to see them twice a month again.

    My now five year old asked me to go to walmart and get him a new daddy, now he says his dad is at work when he’s thinking of him and not able to see him. My eleven year old recently told me to start dating, he wants a positive guy in his life.

    I’m probably not the person to answer this one.
    alley´s last blog ..Nice My ComLuv Profile

  14. Mama Me says:

    GReetings!

    I read the posts often and feel some speak to parts of my situations, this is my first comment. We’ve experienced alot of what alley speaks of, the absences, inconsistencies and infrequency, coming and going, but being gone longer than available, with the oldest superheroes “Dad.”

    As the children get older, they ask more questions and seem to want more direct answers. So my responses change from moment to moment depending on their need; I share honestly, openly and as positive as possible to address their inquiries or concerns; like “Does he love us?” or “Will I ever see him again?” I share often that these are the choices that their “Dad” is making which they (we) have NO control over. I have borrowed books and videos from the library discussing families and parenting. A video that we all enjoyed and watched several times is the Reading Rainbow with Levar Burton, “Always My Dad(dy)…”

    When asked by a friend, where was his dad, my oldest superhero (9yo) shared that he doesn’t see him often and it was a long story. He said it matter of factly at the time and moved on without incident at that moment.

    And to make it a bit light, the oldest and I would “joke” a teeny bit, when he was in a lighter space, about going to Daddy.com (something we made up) and selecting the “perfect Dad” for him and his brother (but more for him, cause it is more his desire).

    Peace & SUnshine

    p.s. They sent “Dad” emails expressing themselves just yesterday evening, because he is on a 6 month “vacation” and oldest super was asking about him and sharing his feelings. He has written letters to his Dad before and mailed them, but we are unsure of his address now. Emailing was another way for them to express themselves and release what they wanted.

  15. Rachel Sarah says:

    Twitter @ /
    Mama Me: we’re honored that you’ve taken the time to leave such a thoughtful comment. We love what your oldest son said when his friend asked about his Dad….

  16. soulamami says:

    Twitter @ soulamami
    Damn. We’re going through this right now. My daughter’s father is an intermittent, inconsistent presence in her life. He usually manages to roll into town for her bday, and a couple other times a year. But hasn’t called in months. Yesterday, completely unprompted, she declared that doesn’t want Daddy at her birthday party. When I asked her why, she couldn’t really put it into words, so I tried to help her. “Are you mad at him?” Nods. “Do you know why?” Shakes head. So I said, “Well, I’m upset at Daddy too. Wanna know why?” Nods. “I’m upset because I know he makes you upset. I’m upset because, even though I’ve tried everything, he doesn’t visit or call or take care of you. Daddies are supposed to take care of their daughters. But he doesn’t know how to. He loves you, but he can’t take care of you. But I love you. More than anything in this world. And I will ALWAYS take care of you.” The hardest part is me holding back tears. She once told my parents (again out the blue), “Daddy always makes Mommy cry.” That’s the part I need to get better at.

  17. Dr. Leah says:

    Soulamami: Thanks for joining this important conversation. Other moms may feel differently …I believe that it’s healthy for our kids to see an honest expression of our feelings. Holding back tears …especially when you are reassuring your kids that you’re there FOREVER …who among us would not cry?

  18. Twitter @ http://singlemommindy.blogspot.com
    I just popped back over to read the comments here and am sad to be reminded how many kids (and moms) have to deal with this issue.

    And I dont know which is worse; a completely absent father or one that comes and goes only when it suits HIM. My daughter’s father visits about 3 times a year for a couple hours, brings gifts, plays with her and acts like this is perfectly normal and acceptable only to disappear for another 3-6 months before doing it all over again.

    It seems like it would be better for my child and her well being to not have him dangle that carrot and then take it away for the sole purpose easing his guilt (if he has any) or to present an image that he is actually being a loving father (which he is not). As far as I’m concerend, some people who call themselves parents should have no rights at all.
    Mindy@SingleMomSays´s last blog ..Las Vegas Single Mom Birthday Bash My ComLuv Profile

  19. kriz bell says:

    Twitter @ krizbell
    this is a super duper sensitive topic for me- i got pregnant by someone i didn’t know very well who turned out to have very different viewpoints on the world- women and girls in particular. I never told ‘him’ that i was pregnant b/c we stopped seeing each other before i knew i was pregnant and he disappeared- didn’t have a job or his own place when we were seeing each other (red flag? my FAVORITE COLOR!). The reason I stopped seeing him was because after a month of seeing each other he decided to share his muslim fundamentalist beliefs with me. He said it didn’t matter when it was casual but i should know if we were going to proceed- he was on his way back to Cairo to handle family affairs b/c his sisters were protesting the family rule that they not leave the house, let alone to be in public uncovered. Mind you he was enjoying the party life in SF at the time. This turned me off, we broke it off.

    All that to say that I never told him about my daughter. She asks who is my dad? Does he know my name? She assumes we will go see him. As she gets older (this all started the minute she could talk) the age appropriate story gets more elaborate. We are now living with a story that goes something like, some people have different beliefs- where your genetic father comes from they like girls to grow up like Rapunzel. I have a different belief so you are with me. When you are old enough and have enough life practice to know what your beliefs are, then we will do everything we can to find your dad if that is what you want to do.

    He is not bad- he is just different and we don’t know where he is. It breaks my heart- I also tell her that life is full of magic and that there are genetic families and there are families that come from love. you never know what life is made of and someday our family may grow to include a love dad- meanwhile we have plenty of love between us and our dogs.

  20. soulamami says:

    Twitter @ soulamami
    @Mindy. I’m totally with you on that Which is Worse conundrum. I’ve bent over backwards to give LJ a semblance of a relationship with her dad, because I thought that was the right thing to do & I believed that he’d work to better his situation. But 5 years later, he’s still stuck in the same muckety-muck of the Do Nada Tar Pits. Why should she grow up equating her daddy to disappointment? Isn’t it my job to protect her?

    @Dr. Leah. Thanks for your kind words. The tears to which I was referring were my own when talking about or to LJ’s dad. There’s a lot of history & even more heartache. But now, it’s not just my own heart that’s at stake.

  21. Rachel Sarah says:

    Twitter @ /
    @Kriz, thank you so much for sharing your own story here. You’re incredibly brave. That last bit re: maybe having a “love dad” someday really got to me.

  22. Morgan says:

    I couldn’t agree more that making a baby doesn’t make you a parent. Parenting makes you a parent! And that fathers who come and go are harder on the kids (and the mom) than if they would just GO. I was just dealing with this today, left work early to have some time to cry before picking up my daughter from daycare. I am trying to come to terms with the notion that I can’t be the only parent, even though I AM the only parent.

    Kriz I understand what it’s like to suddenly realize your views on the world are on a collision course with the person you’re with. I was with the father of my child only on and off, and much of that was long distance. We also had language and cultural barriers since this all took place while I was living abroad. I let way too much go without comment, because I always told myself, Oh, he grew up in a completely different culture, or Oh, I’m sure he didn’t really mean that the way it sounded to my ears because I was not fluent in the language we spoke.

    So, we split up when my daughter was still newborn. I told him I could not be with him any longer and would not be returning to Russia. And he left the country without even putting up an argument about it! OH THE RELIEF I FELT. I had been prepared to simply stay with him forever out of obligation, and allowing myself to release us from him was wonderful.

    There are good reasons I didn’t want him around us anymore: among them, excessive drinking (followed by requests to hold a newborn baby!!!) and fundamentalist christian nonsense.(Lovely combo.)

    What upset me today is that he emailed (it’s our only contact and comes to ruin my day every 1 to 3 months) saying he “misses” her and “loves” her (how in the world do you miss and love someone you don’t know?? You DON’T! You love the idea, the fantasy.) and wants us to go to Russia for a visit. NO! There are complicated legal reasons why this would be a very bad idea. And besides that, just NO! He is not raising her, I am. He does not carry any of the burdens or make any of the difficult decisions, and in my mind is not entitled to just have the fun “look I’m a daddy” experiences. He talks on and on about “blood” and “family”. Bleh. My daughter and I ARE a family thank you very much, and blood does not make you a daddy.

    As for my daughter, who is almost 2 now, I will not speak ill of him to her. I will be absolutely (age appropriately) factual about her father. And it will be up to her if she wants to Skype with him or exchange emails, or even visit when she is older. I adored my father no matter what wrongs he committed, so I am aware of what is probably in store for me. She won’t see the self-absorbed irritating racist drunk, she’ll see an exotic daddy in a far away land who loves her sooo much. And when people say to me “But you can’t want to keep him away, that’s her DAD”, I see that exact same blindness in them.

    Thanks for letting me vent, I needed that.

  23. Dr. Leah says:

    Morgan: Feel free to vent anytime! You’re a terrific mom …what an incredible story.

  24. Betty says:

    My friends call my daughter’s father “the donor”. We live 3000 miles away. He has another family now. He visited while she was an infant, and that’s it. Sometimes he sends money. Yeah, he’s a deadbeat. I have a lot of anger and luckily my 5 year old doesn’t ask very often.
    I told her that some kids have fathers in their life, and some kids don’t. But what’s most important is that she has a mommy who loves her more than anything else in the world. We’re a team, we work together.

    In the are where we live it’s a little unusual, my sister and I are the only single parents in the kindergarten… great. All the other little kids have two parents, so it has come up more. But, no big deal…I’ve heard her say that her daddy “lives far, far away” and move on to the next subject. She’s got a couple of male figures in her life…. (though, I have to admit it would be good to find a partner and someone to help me raise her….)

  25. Shannon says:

    At 4, my son was at his first playdate and when his friend mentioned something that he had done with his father, I heard my son say, “Oh, I don’t have a father.” He could have been saying that he didn’t have a dog, it was that casual. Recently (at age 6) I heard him say to himself while playing, “I don’t have a daddy, but I have a Grandpa.” OK, that seems like a reassuring thought process. However, my son is now confused about my marital status and I have no idea whether to leave him in ignorance or correct him.

    For background, one day at age 5, after picking him up from preschool/daycare, my son asked if I was married. I said that most people get married before having babies because babies are so much work and it is easier if there are 2 people to share the work. I said that I had wanted him so much that I had him without getting married. That answer seemed to work at that time, but now (a year later) my son is fairly convinced that I must be married. That idea must be coming from school friends. His father knows of his existance but has his own family and wants absolutely nothing to do with my son. That scenario isn’t going to change. So, do I ignore the whole married/not married subject? And if I do ignore it, when is the next bout of questions liable to come? We do have a large extended family of aunts, uncles and cousins, and I try to emphasize how lucky we are to have such a big family and so many people that love us. But there is always the unspoken question in my mind. “When is the next tough question going to come and how will I answer it?” The truth isn’t flattering for either parent, we were both fairly selfish in very different ways. Any suggestions?

  26. Rachel Sarah says:

    Twitter @ /
    @Shannon: Wow, do I relate to your comment!! My own father has been the man in my child’s life.

    Good for you for having so many loving family members and friends in your son’s life — as well as married couples.

    Here’s what has helped me: making a conscious effort to befriend other single moms and spending time with them. (Hopefully, their kids befriend your son, too!). As you meet more single moms, you can naturally introduce the topic of “different kinds of families’ to your son. You might explain to him that some kids are raised by a mom and dad, some are raised by a mom and grandpa, etc.

    Of course, the real point is: your son’s family structure might not look “traditional,’ but he sure is loved. Keep us in touch!

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled
ss_blog_claim=2dba28946b740b47821f4be875666330