Should a man always be told that he’s a father?
by Dr. Leah
Filed under Single Moms
Thank you so much for trusting us at Singlemommyhood with your most troubling relationship issues. We’ve listen as you told us that you’re breaking up when you’re pregnant – or soon after giving birth. We know this has marked one of the most difficult moments in your life. Your stories are powerful.
So, when we received this email last week, it was clear that this single woman was reaching out to YOU as she struggled to make a very important life decision. Here’s what the single mom told us:
“My son is four years old. He has never met his father because I never told the man I got pregnant.”
Apparently, this single mom did not know she was pregnant until she was well into her second trimester. Complicated medical issues had initially masked the pregnancy. So, she was pregnant when they broke up, but she did not know she was pregnant. After they broke up, this former boyfriend went out of his way to damage her career. (They both work in the same industry, but he’s far more “high profile.”)
This single mom grew terrified of his vindictive behavior. When they were dating, she was aware that he took medication. But that was not a relationship deal breaker at the time. Yet as he grew more paranoid and began to stalk her, she knew the relationship had to end. And this is what led her to conclude — reluctantly — that she did not want the biological father to have any role in her child’s life.
Of course, her son has begun to ask the “Daddy questions” now that he’s enrolled in preschool. So far, he seems content with her short answers, and many of his classmates have “real life” families, too. This single mom and her son live a peaceful life, and she cherishes the blessing of her sweet son. Still, this single mom wonders…
Is keeping the identity of the biological father a secret the right decision?
Or does every man have the absolute right to know that he’s a father?
~~~
And speaking of fathers ... You’ll want to read at Boston Globe about a dad who wants a relationship with his son:
Columnist Barbara Metlz interviews Dr. Leah, “my go-to person on this subject,” for right-on advice on this single parent issue, and more!
~~~
(Photo courtesy of Rickz)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ http://notyouraveragesinglemama.com
If mom was afraid of his behavior before….what changed? Is he less of a threat than he was before? What changed in mom’s mind? Just the classmate thing? I mean, I get that, truly I do…it’s a big decision that can and will effect them all for the rest of their lives….just want to make sure that mom & son are SAFE. It sucks ass to be scared of someone day after day….
What has mom been telling son up till now?
Keeping you all in my prayers!! Keep your head up mama…you’ll get thru this~
singlemama_cc´s last blog ..Soundtrack of a PIT
Twitter @ http://singlemommindy.blogspot.com
Under the circumstances described here it sounds to me like the mom made the right choice. Vindictivness is an act of a very disturbed person, and I know first hand how much worse it can be when a “parent” uses his own child to control and manipulate the other parent. The child is better off without that in their life.
Mindy@SingleMomSays´s last blog ..Father’s Day
Twitter @ tashsparkles
The man, no matter how screwy, should be told. You don’t know how his behaviour might change if he knew he has a child. Furthermore, it’s his obligation to provide for his child.
Lastly, do you want your child to heap all his resentment on you? Trust me, as the child of an awesome single mom, I had a ton of resentment re: my father, who wasn’t in my life for almost 20yrs. If your son finds out the reason his father is MIA is that you didn’t inform him of his son’s existance, all the resentment is heaped on you. You don’t deserve that.
Good luck!!!
Twitter @ sincemydivorce
I don’t think it’s black and white that men should always be told they are the father.
By the sounds of it, this mom made the right decision to go it alone. The decision was made with the child’s best interests at heart. When the time comes, she can support her son’s efforts to get in touch with his biological father.
Mandy´s last blog ..Divorced but still married says the Catholic church
Twitter @ http://momandmadness.wordpress.com/
This is a very hard situation, but in my heart, I believe that the father has a right to know. If he is truly a danger to mother and son, then she needs to go through the proper legal procedures (I know it’s not perfect). It’s just not up to her to decide what rights the father has.
What if the roles were reversed? There is a mother who’s unstable and vindictive and has psychological issues. In the hospital, her boyfriend, the baby’s father, decides that it’s in the child’s best interest not to have to deal with his mother so the father kidnaps the baby and convinces the hospital staff to tell the mother the baby died. I know that scenario is unbelievable but would you feel that it’s ok to hide the child’s existence from his mother because she has issues?
A scenario that is more believable and happens a lot more frequently than any of us care to think about would be a father who decides on his own (and with the support of “everyone” who knows her) that Mom is unfit so he snatches the child and runs “for the best interests of the child”. Does Dad have the right to make that decision on his own and determine whether Mom should or shouldn’t have parental rights? Why is it ok for Mom to decide on her own what rights Dad should have but it’s not ok for Dad to interfere with Mom’s rights?
Mothers are assumed to have certain parental rights just by virtue of the fact that we are mothers. Fathers are also parents and should have the same parental rights unless and until it is determined that they are a danger to their children. The legal system is far from perfect but it does provide some checks and balances. It’s far worse to allow one parent to decide and control the other parent’s rights after a breakup. Look around, many of us have been hurt and done wrong and whatever but if we look objectively, we all know some single mothers who are pure evil (you’re probably friends with their ex-husbands…of course none of your friends are that way!) Do we condone dads arbitrarily cutting those mothers out? Where does it end? We need family court reform but hiding the baby’s existence from his father is not the answer.
wondermom´s last blog ..Random
Twitter @ notthecar
I’m sorry she’s wrong. The damage he did to her was after she left him and according to her very professional related. This is why you never mess with someone you work with. Regardless the father is not a danger to her or her son and THAT should be the deciding factor. She’s holding onto the hurt from a realtionship that the aftermath was so wrong. Like Natasha said if he grows up and finds out she never told the father her son may have a ton of deep seeded resentment. And that’s on her.
He is obligated by law to provide for this child but she has no idea whaat would happen if she tells the father. Don’t hide it. The person that will be hurt the most is her son and he will not see her logic when he is an adult.
Twitter @ http://notyouraveragesinglemama.com
I may be the only one who thinks so, or will admit it but
“He is obligated by law to provide for this child” is not a good enough reason to tell him anything.
Here, this is your son by OBLIGATION.
Yeah cause that’s not damaging to a kid
(says a kid by obligation…in therapy…probably not related though)
“This is why you never mess with someone you work with” is a good point but so is don’t scare the fucking beJesus out of someone with your paranoid stalker bit. That shit isn’t cool.
Some dads DO take their children and run when mommy gets strung out, paranoid and a danger to herself and/or the children. Kudos to those dads!
Hell, Kudos to any parent who chooses to keep their child safe rather than damaging their children due to obligation.
We don’t know the whole story behind mom & son, it’s a bit harsh to assume she’s a bitter and vindictive woman who has had her heart broken. Why not assume dad beat the bloody piss out of her? Should she tell an abusive man who she feared anything?
With so many variables to consider the only thing that I would like to offer is….prayers.
singlemama_cc´s last blog ..Music Meme Monday: YOU. Behind the Music.
I think every relationship has its own set of circumstances and that decision is the right of the mother for her situation. For example, I became pregnant with a man who I was, at the time, broken up with (my decision). I did toss in my mind whether he should be told or not. In the end, I told him because I felt it was his right to know. He was separated from his ex for over 2 yrs, wasn’t a US citizen but I thought he was a good father to his child and step-children which drove my decision to tell him. Most importantly, I told him after I made up my mind that I wanted this baby regardless of his reaction. I think it is important for a woman to make her “choice” before the father is told and be prepared for him to both stay in the child’s life or leave. Unfortunately for me, my child’s father decided to stay for 6 months and then changed his mind and left the country (never to be heard from again). I would hope a man would really think through his decision when told he has a child or one on the way and not change their mind like it is a new sneaker choice. It is a big risk to tell a man if no legal ties are established (ex. getting him to sign paternity papers). It is also a risk that he might not stay in the child’s life which I believe is more damaging to come in and out of it than to be out completely (too inconsistent for the child & hurtful). I think she made a good, gut decision & should stay with it until her child is old enough to understand.
Twitter @ reluctantX
Father of 3 boys here.
I think she’s wrong. The father should be told. He should have the opportunity to do what is right and support his child. He may not take it, true, and that’s his choice, but it is unfair to deprive him of that choice.
Wondermom put it best: “It’s just not up to her to decide what rights the father has.”
reluctantX´s last blog ..Drawing the line on emotional involvement
Twitter @ _katarena_
I think she did the right thing! The “father” sounds unstable & dangerous. Would you introduce your child to anyone with those characteristics? I don’t think so. Our children’s safety and well-being should always be our first priority.
When her son is old enough she should sit down and talk to him about why she made the decision that she did. Hopefully he will be able to understand at that point. And if he wants to make contact as an adult that will be his choice.
Kate´s last blog ..Becoming
Twitter @ http://wonderfulbeingagirl.blogspot.com
i didn’t tell him. I had one chance but i had already been counseled not to reveal my situation. When we met I was having a lot of fun being free- on my way on a trip around the world after i directed a play at the Fringe Fest. We saw each other a few times but it stopped when his drinking and i suspect drug use were more than occasional. He informed me of his strict Muslim beliefs- that he and his family subscribed to Sharia law. He told me stories of his sisters’ desire to leave the house and to not be covered and his intention to return home to enforce the tradition by any means necessary.
When I found out I was pregnant almost 3 months later it was with a heavy heart, advice from Middle Eastern male friends and the posters at the post office that all told me the possibility of him or his family kidnapping my child and imposing their belief system on her/us was likely. I was advised to keep it to myself- especially considering his drug use.
My daughter has asked about her father since she could talk. In our lives he is real, he is a future destination. I am honest with her- that he lives far away and has different beliefs. we read the story of Rapunzel and she agrees that she would rather live with her mama out in the big world and looks forward to bringing lots of books for the long ride to find her father when she can make her own decisions. Meanwhile she understands that our family is different, that every family is different and maybe someday we will have a Dad, meanwhile we have all the love we need.
Finally, I am sad about this almost every day and try my hardest to make sure her life is as rich as possible with other things.
Twitter @ http://wonderfulbeingagirl.blogspot.com
i just read some of the comments above- i am interested if i will also be judged- and if the ‘proper legal channels’ will also be advised. You see Sharia law allows that i could be stoned to death simply for adultery. There are no proper legal channels when I have to search the desert of the Middle East to find out where he is hiding her- this happens a lot. I was advised to do what i did by men from the same country as he was- who have children and who know children who have been kidnapped. I stand by my very painful and difficult situation. If you feel your life is danger, that fear extends to your child and the law is far too imperfect to risk the margin of error.
krizbell´s last blog ..Two Women Walk Into a Frame
Twitter @ http://www.jane-sliceoflife.com/
Interesting. All men should be told they have children. However, how they are told, can make a big difference and should be explored. She does not need to be the one to tell him.
What is interesting is, the fact that she is even considering this. If she truly felt so threatened, I would like to imagine this as a done deal in her head, and there would be no discussion, no matter how cute and curious her 4 year old is. Dad is dead, sort of deal. Is this right? Nor for me to judge, but for our kids we do move mountains, however this does need to be for the right reasons. When her four year old is 21 and wants to know where his roots are, she needs to have an understandable answer to explain to the man she helped raise.
Jane´s last blog ..Parenting- A mans POV
I don’t know if this relates but My mother had a daughter a year before she had me. She did not tell the father. My half sister is in alot of trouble now (35 years later)and needs medical help for major mental and health problems.
She called me begging for help last night and I didn’t know what else to do. I called her father and told him about his daughter today. I know it was not my place but I didn’t know where else to turn. In my oppinion, it’s not fair to any man or woman to not be told or to be lied to like that. This news could ruin his life at the point all because his own daughter was kept a secret.
To not tell them is to lie and nothing good can come of it when done for selfish reasons like convenience.
Danielle France: We’re stunned by your comment. What a painful and terrible dilemma. You really had no other choice. We’re keeping you in our thoughts. Do keep us posted. We care what happens.
Twitter @ theslynch
Wow. I guess in reading all of the comments–the “father issue” really does need to be addressed in a case by case basis. And, yet, I would ASSUME that the father ALWAYS needs to know. In the end, I think that NOT telling will clearly make the mother’s life easier. Telling becomes hard for everyone–if the father and the mother cannot get along. All I can say is, as hard as it was for me to watch my son’s father walk away, I’m thankful that he did. HE made the choice and I never had to make the choice for him.
In terms of the mother with the 4 year-old, I would think in that situation you need to tell him. Although he might have been scary and annoying to the mother, there isn’t any evidence that he, or more importantly HIS FAMILY, would not be warm and loving to this child. Because it’s not just about the father. It’s about the grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins–they all have a right to know this child–to love him. If you utilize the legal system–you can protect the child from the father if he’s mentally unstable. It may not be exactly how you want it to be–BUT–if the father or father’s family would be receptive–it would be better for the boy. In the end–you never know. Given the choice and information–they may opt out of the boy’s life. And, then your problem is solved. He knows–and made his own choice.
I know I work hard to keep my son’s father’s family involved. I’m lucky–they have been amazingly supportive and loving of my son–regardless of the lack of involvement of their own son in their grandson’s life. I know this is best for my son. I know that he will feel stronger about who he is–his sense of self and identity–because of it.
Sure, I want him to be like me–think like me–vote like me–make choices like me. But, in the end–he’s not. Our children are their own people. They will have their own paths and their own hurts. We can’t protect them from who they are–no more than we can protect them from the choices they make in marriage or career.
*In terms of @krizbell’s comments. I’m not sure I can respond to that. I don’t feel capable of addressing the myriad of cultural and political issues at play in her daughter’s life…I like others…can only send prayers.
Thanks for the thoughts. I guess I am afriad of what happens next for my sister and I am not sure if either will forgive me to telling the father. It was a matter of concience for me. Now I cross my fingers and hope for the best. To make matters worse, my sister was given up for adoption and her father seems to be a good man so far. (I really hate Oprah moments)
I agree that it would be a case by case basis. If there is an undeniable threat to your child life or health, I could understand.
Doing the right thing is never easy in any aspect of life. Being fair to our children can be the most difficult of all. I have a feeling this occurs more than anyone knows being that we live in an age of convenience.
I think the mother made the right choice in not telling this guy she was pregnant. Past behavior usually predicts future behavior. These men are vindictive abusive bullies who usually start custody battles in an effort to control the child’s mother or punish her because she ran away from his abuse. For crying out loud, read the papers. These are the same kind of men who end up killing the mothers and/or the children. No, this guy shouldn’t have been told when she was pregnant, and he shouldn’t be told now. Spare me the people can change crap. These men seldom do. I’ve worked in domestic violence advocacy, and I’ve seen more than enough of this kind of vindictive controlling behavior. And believe me, these guys love to start custody battles. If she tells the father now, she might as well be prepared for a custody battles. It’s not worth it. If the son wants to meet his father when he is old enough for the father not to be a threat, fine, but until than, I wouldn’t advise it.
Carol: Thank you for adding your expert opinion on this wrenching topic. Please visit us again soon.
Just an Update –
My half sister is still in a lot of trouble. I spoke with her father and although he seemed to take the news well, he is now avoiding me. He has assumed I want money and is avoiding me. I suppose there is no set rule to the behavior of a man in his 50′s finding out he has a grown daughter that he never knew about.
Man I hate Oprah moments
Twitter @ militantmommy
she dated him, gave the relationship a chance, and became fearful of him, and for good reason. Just because one of his sperm ran into one of her eggs, doesn’t mean that he is now allowed to spread his bi-polar reactions to an innocent child. I would simply say, if I had to, that dad was sick and not able to be a father to him. When he is older, the truth can be told, maybe.
courtney´s last blog ..single mom advice about swearing
courtney: Thanks for joining the conversation. Listening to your own fear often provides just the information we need to keep our kids and us safe. Please visit us again soon.
I’m in a situation where the bio father is 20 hours away from me and i’m very close with his mother who lives close to me. While visiting her son, in a moment of weakness we had a one night stand. He is married with three small children. I’m 38 and never thought i would have children and always wanted one so while i was overjoyed I was and am fearful of letting him know because I do not want to hurt his children. I do not want to seek any type of support from him (he is broke anyway). Several of his family members know about our child. This secret has become almost too much for me to bare. His mother wants the child to call her Nana however when he gets older I believe he needs to know she is his “real” Nana. She has not even told her husband that she is his real Nana. I desperately need advice. My son is only 7 weeks old right now however I don’t want to wait until he is old enough to ask who his father is.
@Mary: We’re really glad that you reached out to us. We’d like to hear more about what you’re going through, and the decisions you need to make. Please write to us off line at singlemommyhood [at] gmail [com].
We hope to hear from you soon.