Can a relationship with a parent do more harm than good?
When we talked about “no show” co-parents, you enthusiastically agreed that a Plan B was essential. You told us that relying on a parent who routinely disappoints — by breaking promises — is a BIG mistake. We heard you loud and clear. After all, having alternate plans is a great way to limit kid disappointment and inevitable meltdowns.
We’ve received lots of emails from many of you, updating us on how you’re handling this sensitive co-parenting dilemma. When we got this particular note, however, we felt strongly that this issue needed to be shared with YOU … the real experts.
Here’s what a single mom with a two-year old daughter told us:
Last weekend, her daughter’s dad failed to show up on Sunday. For the record, her daughter was the product of a brief fling. This mother never had a genuine relationship with her child’s father. Their custody and child support agreement was worked out by their respective attorneys. His involvement with their child has always been limited.
Apparently, Dad flew in for the weekend to see his daughter, whom he had not seen in almost a year. On Saturday, he spent a couple of hours with his daughter accompanied by a “friend”. Early Sunday morning, he just sent a text saying something unexpected had come up.
We agree with this single mom’s assessment: “My daughter is almost two, so she doesn’t understand all of this yet. But, she will soon.”
This single mom is grappling with some tough issues: the Plan B idea is appealing, but she worries that a parent who repeatedly breaks promises creates a distrustful and unhappy child. She does want her daughter to have a relationship with her father.
Yet it’s impossible to escape this fact: this Dad has not contacted his daughter since he skipped his Sunday parenting time. And his text made it clear that he has no plans to see his daughter for at least another year. This is not a long distance co-parenting situation. At best, this little girl will see her father once a year for an afternoon. Perhaps, when she’s older, Dad may have a change of heart. But, for now, she hears little to nothing from him.
Here’s what’s tugging at this single mom’s heart:
Should she try to *force* a father/daughter relationship by encouraging more parenting time?
Or should she just accept that Dad only wants a quick yearly visit?
Can sporadic contact with an emotionally distant parent potentially do more harm than good?
If so, would it be best for her daughter to have no contact whatsoever with Dad?
~~
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ NkdGirlinaDress
Thanks for bringing another great topic for us to share as a community of moms.
At the risk of sounding preachy and judgmental, there should not be a forced relationship with this “father.” It sounds like he chose to have a brief fling, but didn’t choose to be a dad. If he doesn’t want to be a dad, forcing interaction would be the worst possible scenario for the child.
If you look from the child’s perspective, it is pushing her into a relationship where she will not feel loved. This child will continually be met with rejection and the feeling of not being loved by a parent if mom pushes her on dad.
As she becomes older, she will begin to wonder what is wrong with her. What has she done wrong for dad not to love her? This is setting her up for relationship problems later in life.
The best thing for this mom is to embrace being a full-time single mom and cut the sperm donor out of this child’s life.
Unfortunately, I speak from experience. Not the exact situation, but similar enough. I made peace with the relationship (or lack thereof) with my father, but it was a long, hard road to find that peace within me.
I wish this mom much luck with this difficult decision.
Naked Girl in a Dress´s last blog ..5 Reasons I Love Being a Mom hint- Rummikub
Twitter @ http://locsandlittleones.blogspot.com
My situation with my son’s father is not as extreme as this one. But I have seen how it’s affected my son. I’m not happy with it. But mine is because his dad used to be very active in his life and only recently stopped showing up.
I think she should just deal with the once a year visits. If he isn’t being abusive, per se, I don’t think he should be cut out. Not for his sake, but so that his daughter will know who she is. Even if she comes to find her dad is an ass, she will know who he is. Make sure that she knows how much mom loves her and will always be there. If there are better and more consistant male role models around, she’ll look to them.
Unfortunately, if he’s going to be an ass, there’s nothing anyone can do about it. That’s the lesson that I’ve learned over the last year.
fexiafromom´s last blog ..little victories
I don’t think you can force more parenting time. Especially if he lives so far away that he needs to fly in (that is expensive and it really isn’t fair to hold against him). But I also don’t think it’s wise to cut him off, at least not yet.
Once yearly visits aren’t ideal. But they aren’t nothing either. He may show more interest when she’s older and easier to relate to. He may also loose interest.
I think there is a danger in protecting a child from all potential hurt, she’s also prevented from experiencing the full range of life’s ups and downs. The dad may always be a disappointment, but he may not. Don’t force him into that role. That makes you the bad guy.
alley´s last blog ..Revelations
Twitter @ aprilabtbalance
I have tried so hard to make sure the girls have a relationship with their father, and it’s still hard to accept that it’s just not going to happen. Sadly, we cannot control someone else in this manner. I can give you all the platitudes (which are true, but admittedly, not very comforting) that it’s his loss in the end, that she’ll grow up stronger because of it. But it doesn’t make it suck any less.
April´s last blog ..Just so proud right now
Twitter @ http://1000reasonsimabadmom.com
Some of us chose to be single moms, and I think we should strive to remember that choice at times like this. The child’s biological father may or may not care for them, and his position is not likely to change. We do NOT have a nuclear family, and that is JUST FINE.
What I am trying to do – what we as single moms *have* to do – is to reinvent these old roles. I, for one, am not going to have my son call his biological father “dad” or anything like it. He will call him by his first name and know who he is, and they will meet when it is convenient for everyone.
Original Poster: please don’t worry about this man. Make sure your daughter recognises and cherishes all those who love her and are part of her life, and let this man be a sort of ‘sailor’ who stops at her port occasionally bearing gifts (which he’d better!!) but not somebody who is part of her family.
Best wishes!
ofthesea´s last blog ..Reason 54 – I refuse to give my baby Early Stimulation
Twitter @ http://mommasunshine.wordpress.com
I don’t think it’s the mom’s responsibility to make sure that the father has a relationship with his child. I am firm believer in not making excuses for someone else’s poor behaviour, even if that person is the child’s parent. If the dad is a no-show and the mom doesn’t know why, then she should tell her daughter exactly that, and (when she’s older) encourage her to ask her dad directly. People need to be accountable for their actions, particularly when their children are involved.
Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..Speak Up! If I could choose any superpower- it would be…
Twitter @ heathergw
I agree with Momma Sunshine.
It’s the dad’s responsibility to create and foster a relationship with his child.
Why do custodial parents feel it’s their responsibility to manage the relationship that others have with their child? I understand that it’s the parent’s job to monitor the child’s relationships, to ensure the child’s safety. But, since it would seem rather odd if a friend began to interfere with your relationships, why is it that familial relationships are so easily and freely interfered with?
You can’t create something that doesn’t exist. If a parent wants little or no contact with their child, it’s not the responsibility of anyone but that parent to make that choice.
As the parent fully involved in the child’s life, it is your responsibility to love and support your child, not to become or replace the absent parent.
*please excuse my bad grammar*
Lauren: Thanks for joining the conversation. Your writing is just fine! Please visit us again soon. (HUG)
Twitter @ http://www.howdoesshedoitmom.com
These are such hard lines to draw and to clearly understand what to do is almost next to impossible. In my experience this comes from trial and error. While my ex husband is around a little more consistently than the dad in this picture my kids haven’t been without their struggles on the issue.
I call him an absent dad…he is around when he wants to be and never goes beyond what is required of him by the custody agreement. My kids are 7 and 5 now and have started to ask more questions… particularity my son who is the older of the two.
I spent two years sheltering their Dad and making excuses for him so as not to hurt their feelings. I did not want them to feel anymore sadness than they had to. In the beginning I begged their Dad to call them regularly…forcing any form of a relationship did not work (but hey I tried, as per the trial and error part). When that didn’t work is when I started sheltering them. I did not want to bad mouth him to them…telling them things like their dad didn’t have time to call them just did not sit right with me.
Anyhow now they are older…they can’t understand why their dad is only around 2 times a month. They are confused about the mix of emotions of missing him and being angry at him at the same time.
I have to say that I think honesty is the best thing…now I think that at least! I decided to no longer try to force anything on him (especially after he requested joint custody and I offered it to him only to have him change his mind at the last minute and devestate my kids)! So I will tell you when I decided to let him make his decisions and be honest with my kids along the way…the day my son looked at me and blamed me for the fact that they didn’t get to go live with him!!
WHOOOOAA! Did that ever have to be nipped in the bud! I explained very kindly that I had offered their daddy something that he refused. That I knew they were upset about it but it was not my fault! I have since had a teary boy on two occasions who is trying to understand why his daddy doesn’t want him more…
but I will tell you this…my job is to raise my kids, to love my kids and the teach them. My job is not to shelter a man for the sake of his well being to sacrifice his emotions.
I say let the man make his choices and then do what most single moms do exceptionally well…hold your babies in your arms and make it all better!!
Carrie Campbell´s last blog ..What Can You Do With Your Life…
Twitter @ http://www.jane-sliceoflife.com/
I seem to have a rather different take on this type of situation. I am, and have been a single, sole custodial, parent for 15 years. I do not believe that children should be told the truth, as many adults put it. Kids know more than we ever think they know, and they know when someone wants to be around them. Most parents, when they are not custodial, and even in intact marriages, when they are around their kids, alone, without the custodial parent, are somewhat uncomfortable. It is just the way it is in our culture. Throw into the mix, single custodial parent, and all kinds of emotions get thrown into the mix, that don’t “really” involve the children.
Our ideas of who our children’s bio parents are and aren’t, changes over time, and don’t ever end up being who we thought they were going to be or who we want them to be. And some of us, over time, are wonderfully surprised. It is our job, as parents to be able to keep that door open for our children. We have no right to tell them how to feel, or act or behave on such a personal issue as their other parent, who is no longer in our personal and intimate lives. Life is full of disappointment, yes this is true. It is how we as the custodial parent handle the disappointment that our children learn. Are we frustrated, angry, trash talk, or do we come up with a solution, a B plan that deals with what is, in a rational manner, and move on, and put things in their right place for the child to deal with on their own emotive level. And deal with our won issues privately, not in front of our children. Take it as it comes, so to speak.
A lot of non custodial parents are clueless when it comes to their kids, and need time to learn. We may not like it, but it is certainly not covering for mistakes or their inadequacies as a parent. They just don’t know yet, and true, they may never, but that is for our children to learn as they get older, how to work out their differences with who their parent is as they get older. Kids roll a lot better than we do, as we live by schedules and our own lives. It is our job, as custodial, to give the best opportunity we can, for our children to foster a relationship over time with their other parent.
Whether we do or not, the day will come, when our children will still come to us, and ask why? While it is true what Carries says above, we do hold our babies well, in our arms and make it all better, there comes a time, years down the line, when those babies, want to know who the other parent is, and will want to know why they did not have the opportunity to work out a relationship with their other parent. Do we want them coming to us in rage, and hormonal anger? Or do we want them coming to us for counsel?
Its been a tough call for me with my four, and thus far, three out of four have come for counsel. I am fortunate. I feel it is best to take it as it comes, and not judge and control what I have very little control over. My kids have a father now that they are older, they didn’t have a dad growing up, and I have to say, what they have, is at times far better than what some of their friends have from intact families, and single families. They accept him for who he is, nothing more and nothing less, and it works for them. And…he is their father.
Jane´s last blog ..Parenting- A mans POV
Twitter @ http://www.howdoesshedoitmom.com
I would definitely qualify my ex as an “absent dad”. There is so much more to being a dad than picking your kids up every second Friday at 6 playing with them all weekend and dropping them off on Sunday at 6.
He has no idea of things like…when they start school, their report cards, when to take them to the doctor, when they last went to the dentist.
He never calls in between visits and he has claimed in the past that is because it makes him feel sad to talk to them !! OMG!!! It’s a good thing he has his priorities straight…..
Carrie Campbell´s last blog ..What Can You Do With Your Life…
Twitter @ http://www.howdoesshedoitmom.com
Jane to add to what you commented on I have to say I 100% agree that I want my kids to come to me to talk..and not in a rage. That is why I always stay neutral and calm when they ask me questions about their Dad. They were taught from the time that I left their father that they can talk to me about anything..that has truly gotten us a long way!!
Carrie Campbell´s last blog ..What Can You Do With Your Life…
Twitter @ http://www.jane-sliceoflife.com/
Kudos to you Carrie! And thank you for adding that…and guess what? In their 20′s, those hugs heal too! Unfortunately, I don’t see much of that type of communication at all, at least not in the life I have lived with my kids, and in our communities. With four girls, and eight years between the oldest and the youngest, people say they promote this within their kids, but I am appalled at some of the things I hear parents say to their kids, even as teens! As regular statements! And…sometimes, it is so so hard…but, it is well worth it! I however, do not let my kids talk to me about “anything”…as several of my friends have found out when their kids have gotten older…but that is an inside joke if you get it! I just want to know they are good with their choices, if they need some counsel, and did they learn from their experience. But…this is a whole other discussion for different age ranges! Have a great day!
Jane´s last blog ..Parenting- A mans POV
Twitter @ http://notyouraveragesinglemama.com
My mother forced me to go to my dads….I’m 30 now and my father and I are still not friends. You can’t force a bond….it’s not up to mom.
singlemama_cc´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday