Should this single mom give up custody?

We’ve met many exceptional moms and dads via Twitter — and we’re honored to be a part of your lives. When this single mom blogger reached out to us via Twitter, however, we felt humbled by her daily challenges. We were also stunned by the heart-wrenching choice she now faces. We’re asking you — please — to help this mama decide about a possible temporary custody arrangement.

Here’s what happening:

“My 11 year-old son and I — and our dog — are homeless,” she began. “We’ve been ‘couch hopping’ for several months. So far, we have not had to sleep in the car, and I feel lucky for that.”

This mama is homeless because she’s unemployed. She lost her job about six months ago. Like many of us, she lives pay check to pay check, so the job loss was devastating. We get it.

Fortunately, she’s got family support. Her brother is career military, having just completed his third tour in Iraq. He’s now home safely –about 1,000 miles from his sister — with his wife and teen-aged kids. Immediately upon his return,  he contacted his sister via cellphone for a serious conversation.

During this conversation, her brother offered to take custody — not legally — of her son for one year so she’d have the chance to get her life back together. He was not accusing or judgmental, just very concerned about her son. And it was clear — from his carefully chosen words — she and the dog are not invited.

This mama is grateful for her brother’s offer of a stable — and loving — temporary home for her son. She respects her brother’s perspective, and the limited space in his home.

Of course, she’s torn apart by a flood of feelings. She does not want to be separated  from her son. He’s the inspiration to get her life together  — and she’d miss him like crazy. She realizes, however, that her son cannot bear the burden of her emotional well-being: that’s too much responsibility for a child.

On the other hand, her brother has everything she’s ever wanted for her son. He wouldn’t feel lonely and isolated — as he does now. He’d get to know his extended family. Her brother would provide the male role model lacking in her son’s life. Being military, her brother is strict — not harsh — and consistent.  She feels her brother’s home environment would be good for her son.

This mama can’t shake this thought: maybe her son won’t want to come back. In hindsight — always 20/20 — she realizes that she’s made some foolish choices. But, she also knows that beating herself up for past choices isn’t helpful.  Right now, she needs a clear head to make the right choices.

So, this mother is asking for your advice:

Should she accept her brother’s offer?

Do you feel this is the best choice for her son — for now?

Or should this mama make a different choice?

If so, what do you think this mama should do?

~~~

Photo via Flickr: ryandigital

Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges.
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style.

No related posts.

Comments

28 Responses to “Should this single mom give up custody?”
  1. Lorraine says:

    Twitter @
    I don’t thing she should give up custody. Even though the circumstances are hard, I think she will send the wrong message to her son on what to do when faced with adversity. The brother is selfish in a way because instead of trying to keep the family together, he is breaking it more apart. The brother could have offered some other form of support without the sister having to move in with the brother. Sometimes people only need to know they have some one supporting them emotionally to get their life back on track. Too many legal implications can arise by her giving “custody” of her son as this can be interpreted as abandonment and/or neglect. The brother and sister need to sit down and discuss alternative methods of assisting.

  2. Dr. Leah says:

    Lorraine: We appreciate your thoughtful comment — this mama really needs our help.

  3. Cari says:

    Twitter @
    Wow! That is so tough. I think she needs to devise a very detailed plan. Has she looked into to all of her options? There is so much support out there for folks in need to help you get back on your feet, I would go with that first. I would not give up custody, but if her son needs a stable home for the moment, I would do it, and get some conditions in writing.

    Just this week, there was a local story, Lakeville, Minnesota, of a father that left his eleven year old son home alone with a note. The note said, he was leaving, he was jobless and their house was in foreclosure. It said he loved him, but could not drag his son down with him. The child ran crying to a neighbors home. This man was obviously desperate, and had reached rock-bottom. The man is now facing child neglect charges, and I’m sure his son is scarred for life.

    I have no answers, I thank God daily that my family is here to help me. Best of luck, and prayers your way.

  4. Dr. Leah says:

    Cari: Thanks for joining this difficult conversation. Getting something in writing with her brother is definitely worth considering.

  5. Angela says:

    Twitter @
    Under these circumstances? No. It is too easy to assume children only need financial support but the love of a parent means more than food to most children. Her son will definitely feel as though she abandoned him. If her brother really wants to help, he could use the money he would use to relocate, house, clothe and feed his nephew, to help his sister get back on her feet and leave her family intact. However, if she is truly suffering some mental health issues it would be better to send her son to her brother but ONLY if she moved as well so she can maintain a relationship with her son.

  6. Teri says:

    Twitter @
    Why does custody have to an issue? The mother should move to the same town as her brother, have her children live with the her brother until she can find a job. There may be a shelter where the mother can be with her children until she can get on her feet. Living in the same town as a member of her family would give her additional support. It would be nice if the brother could move them to the same town. There must be some underlying issue with the relationship between her and her brother. Unfortunately the children are always the one’s that suffer.

  7. Teri says:

    Twitter @
    Maybe temporary custody ??

  8. Rscort says:

    I would wonder why he wouldn’t let her move in also, if he is frequently deployed — saying space is an issue, but he wouldn’t be there. I would go to the salvation army for shelter and employment help

  9. Dr. Leah says:

    Rscort: We’re not sure why. We do know that is what he told this mama. Thanks for joining the conversation.

  10. Avigail74 says:

    Twitter @
    Mama doesn’t need to give up custody~ ever. I don’t trust the “temporary” custody thing anyway~ our schools have what’s called~ oh shoot, it slipped my mind~ but it’s for when a child is living with someone else and the person who is “at the moment” responsible for that child can make decisions for education and medical~ BUT the parents are still involved. Never ever give up custody. I do like what others have suggested, move to the town where the brother lives (that is ONLY if he’s going to be respectful of the mother, his sister)~ keep the child with her while getting back on her feet. Maybe his house can be the “visiting” house~ where the child stays on weekends or after school until mom gets home. From my experience as a teacher who works in low-income schools, children usually prefer to stay with their parents, regardless of the situation.
    Avigail74´s last blog ..The Four Day TripMy ComLuv Profile

  11. Avigail74 says:

    Twitter @
    Also….there are lots and lots of resources for homeless people~ especially those with children. It does require lots looking, frustration, and persistency~ above all, trust that there is something out there. Perhaps, start with social workers~ they’re usually awesome people and their entire job revolves around getting people back on their feet. You can even find social workers in transitional homes. Good luck!
    Avigail74´s last blog ..The Four Day TripMy ComLuv Profile

  12. mightbeatranny says:

    Twitter @
    i agree with the above suggestion of moving to the city where her brother lives and letting the son stay w/ her brother while mom gets her act together. but ask yourself this; is your brother kind, caring, patient, up to being a parent? is he acting out of love? would your child be better off in his care if your situation continues? do you have a history of substance abuse? does your brother? when stress goes up, old habits often return.

    the dog needs to go. you can’t be worrying about providing for an animal when you can’t provide for yourself or your child. not judging, just saying.

    as for giving up custody, i’m not sure why you would need to do that. if you decide to take your brother up on his offer, you should sign something so that he can make medial decisions and get you son enrolled in school. it doesn’t need to be custody, and it can be stated that it is temporary.

    if there is a history behind this story, where your brother or somene else is always coming to your rescue then i suspect this is an attempt to get custody. if thats true you need to think about what this means. not just for you but for your child.

    this is NOT going to solve all your problems. you son won’t magically feel
    less lonely and isolated just because of where he’s living. there will be adjustments. this solves a certain portion of your issues that will allow you to focus on other areas.

    if you do this. i would have a talk with your son saying that his uncle is super excited to spend time with HIM and put it out there like it is really a great opportunity. and have a time line in effect. when you will move there. when you will start job training. when you will have a place. and then stick to it mom.

    good luck

  13. Brandon says:

    Twitter @
    I agree, this is a tough call. You have to worry about the message you are sending the child, that is for sure. Then again, what are you telling them by being unstable and worried?

    I do agree that there is probably something else to the brother/sister relationship. It strikes me as a little odd that he would say ‘you aren’t welcome’ at least temporarily. Something doesn’t smell right there.

    As for the custody, there are several reasons I have seen military do this. Many of the involve benefits, which he would not be able to provide without custody. I will give benefit of doubt and say that is the reason. And, custody can also be given stipulations and time frames.

    There are too many unknowns to really offer advice, but I would say she needs to decide what her plan is. If she is willing to sleep on a couch, she should be willing to take just about any moral job to save money and get healthy again. If she’s unwilling? The kid would be better off with a stable person. Just my opinion.
    Brandon´s last blog ..Empowering Girls – The process beginsMy ComLuv Profile

  14. Kristen says:

    Something fishy going on here. Why on earth would he insist on separating his sister from her kid unless she has issues (or he, the brother) does. There’s something missing from this story.

  15. Jennifer W says:

    Twitter @
    This is long, but I’ve been in this situation as a kid and as the adult so here goes…

    After my mom left my dad, we slept in our station wagon or on the floor of our aunts & uncles homes for months until he found work & a place to live. As a teen, I lived with my mom but she & my stepdad had substance abuse issues. I was ‘given’ to an uncle and his GF for a while until my mom found a place to live & found a job. I resent my mom for abandoning me, & I praise my dad for doing everything he could to keep our family together even while living in a car. My siblings & I survived my dad’s couch hopping unscathed, and we’re all productive members of society. We now know how to work through the worst of times to survive.

    I was also homeless when my son was born. My dad took us in, and then later my cousin did, but there was conflict & I went into transitional housing for homeless families. Whether her situation is drama from the past, mental or emotional disorders, or substance abuse, her brother has a right not to ask her to come if he knows it will seriously disrupt his house. She has the right to say, “No thank you, it’s me & my son or nothing.” The dog has to go, period. You cannot support an animal when you have kids & have nowhere to live. Her son will NOT understand why she kept the dog with her & not him.

    IMHO, she shouldn’t give custody to the brother. Either get a better support system where she is or move closer to her brother somehow for help babysitting or whatever. Churches are huge helps even if you don’t attend them. There are resources out there for single moms with kids who are homeless. Catholic Charities, Salvation Army, and even social services can give referrals. Search ‘transitional housing’ online. Whether she quickly finds a part time job in retail, fast food, or some online WAH job she’ll need to have something to get into transitional housing. She’s really going to have to put in work to try to get help for herself & her son. It can be done but it’s really hard. I feel for her.

  16. diane says:

    Take the brothers offer~ Lots of cultures do this. Many US families send their kids to private boarding school even as young as Jr. High.

    Are we worried about bonding and attachment at this stage of the game? Or are we talking about waking up each day happy and full and feeling worthy to face school mates?

  17. Jess says:

    This is a tough choice to make. And not knowing the entire story and background of the mom makes it tougher. We all want the best for our children. Unconditional love is so important. I think she should not send her son away to live with the brother, unless she is going to. Times are not only tough for her but her son also. He lost everything else with being homeless, he doesnt need to lose his mother too. The brother was very nice offering the nephew to stay and have a stable life, but he should have offered an open door to his sister as well. It will be easier and faster for her to get back on her feet, as opposed to living day by day different places. I hope that they can talk this out and both can stay with her brother together temporarily. God bless that family and I pray it will all work out for the best.

  18. Anna says:

    I wouldn’t even give up custody for benefits. Every state has a health care program for kids whose parents aren’t insured. I agree with Avigail74. If the brother wants to help, his house can be the weekend and/or after school house, while mom, living in the same town, gets back on her feet.

  19. Casey says:

    Twitter @
    My first blog post is my response (especially the portion in bold letters), but in short – it should be done through lawyers, official paperwork with witnesses. With that much stress on the situation, I’m not sure I would relinquish custody for any amount of time.
    Casey´s last blog ..first postMy ComLuv Profile

  20. Dr. Leah says:

    Casey: We’re honored that you chose responding to our post as your first blog entry. Thank you for joining the conversation in such a meaningful way.

  21. MWC26 says:

    Twitter @
    I wanted to expand on what Brandon said, the brother would need custody if he the nephew was to recieve any benefits from him under the military (at least that was how it was when I was in the military). But at the instilation (military base) where I lived, if the family was living on post (as I was with my ex an our child when we were married), in order for someone to live with you on post, they had to be your dependent, as in you had to have custody of that child. In fact a friend of mine who had married a man with two children from his previous marriage, had to have his ex wife sign over physical custody of thier son just so his own son could come and live with his father. The instilation even based the number of rooms of the house they assigned to based on the number of children you had. For example, because my ex and I had one child, we got a house with a master bedroom and 1 extra room. My friend who’s step son came to live with them, was moved to a bigger house with two extra bedrooms because she had a daughter, and then the stepson. So there may be reasons as to why the brother might need custody for those housing reasons, if they live on post and have strict housing rules like the military base I lived on.

    I can however agree, if the brother does not have those restrictions or doesn’t live on post it could be a little fishy. But the mom does admit to have had making poor choices in her past, and I wonder if the brother is afraid he may end up paying for future mistakes or if he has had to help her with the past bad choices, and just does not want to help her. But giving up custody? That is a major decision. I don’t know if I could.

    I have a brother who has made some horrible life choices, flunked out of 4 different colleges, and is just down right rude, nasty, and argumentative with everyone. He has past girlfriends who have accused him of hitting them after they breakup, and even has been fired from 1 job for getting into a fist fight with someone! He won’t cook, clean up after himself, or even treat you with a shred of decency when you are doing something for him. I once got into a huge fight with my mother when she asked if he could live with me, and I told her absolutely not, and I told her that she couldn’t even live with him, it wasn’t right for her to ask me to. I wouldn’t even leave my child alone with him, and all that time I was pregnant. He is family, but everyone has thier breaking point. We don’t know the full story here, and there seem to be a lot of holes in the story we are given. This mom’s brother may sound like a jerk, but he could have his reasons for either not wanting to have his sister move in, or he may just not be allowed to.

  22. C Lo says:

    Twitter @
    I hate to say it but I agree with Kristen……….if it were me and *I* were offering to take my siblings child and NOT help my sibling it would be because there is something else going on.

    I can’t imagine willingly giving up my child. But then again if that’s even an option for this mama, maybe the kid might be better of with someone who won’t.

    I can’t even imaging the damage it would do to a kid to know that his parent would consider giving him away.
    C Lo´s last blog ..3 weeks, car-freeMy ComLuv Profile

  23. Michelle says:

    Twitter @
    I am humbled by all the responses.

    Two issues have been pointed out above all others and this is EXACTLY why I sought out objective feed back from this site. An uninvolved person can sort through things much easier then the one personally affected. There is just too much emotion involved to clog your decision making. Here are the two most helpful trends that your great responses have revealed to me:

    1.) Something strange about my relationship with my brother. Keen observation. The something strange permeates my whole immediate family. I grew up in an abusive household where the example set by our father was anger and violence and the example set by my mother was neglect and disengagement.
    I don’t think any of us ever felt loved or safe as children. What we learned was this, fend for yourself, seek help outside of our home. As the youngest, 9 yrs younger then my brother and 6 yrs younger then my sister, they bore the brunt of the violence. My father fell ill when I was 10 and died when I was 13.
    Because of his health I didn’t suffer the beatings they had. But I suffered my mother’s neglect. She hooked up with my father’s best friend 6 months after my fathers death and I rarely saw her.
    My 19yr old sister became my primary care taker. She hates helping me. She lost her childhood to doing so and now intentionally distances herself from it.
    My brother escaped into military life and that is where he had made his home.
    I don’t think I wasn’t welcome to stay with him, only that he assumed I would want to stay in CT and establish myself here instead of Texas, where he lives.
    After he made the offer to have my son stay with him, I thought he’d be happy when I called him to say we’d found a place and willing to contribute some money for the down payment I was trying to raise. Social services was a huge help, donating half, and my friends donated more, but my brother said he couldn’t give any. I thought it was weird, but my experiences over the last few months have taught me, everybody is comfortable giving certain things, while being very unwilling to share others.
    Some were more then happy to hand over money, but wouldn’t feel comfortable offering us a room in their house. Others were the opposite. I decided to be grateful for either. The good news is this: we got the apartment and are no longer homeless. No more couch hopping. Which brings me to astute reader observation

    2.) Stick through the hard times together. Had I not gotten this apartment, my son would probably be on his way to Texas. I could not see him suffer one more day of not knowing where he was going to lay his head. But I guess we stuck it out just long enough. And it paid off. I have two part time jobs on the horizon ( so I will be working full time) and we, including my dog, are still together. Happiness.

    Two things that surprised me most:
    1.) The suspicion that I may be a drug user or mentally unstable. No. I’ve never even smoked a cigarette or been drunk. I do suffer from OCD and tourettes syndrome, but have never found these issues to interfere with my ability to work or form relationships. My family is just damaged. Its easier for my brother to offer to help my son because he is a child. I’m expected to handle myself, to not need help. That has been the expectation since my father died. So, that’s that.

    The other surprise was how easily everyone said “get rid of the dog”. That was the one disheartening trend I found. Shelby has been with me since she was 14 weeks old. She is now 12 and a half years. She is not a person, I know, but she does have feelings, real ones. Dogs dedicate their lives to their families. It is an unconditional love that I haven’t experienced any other time, including from my mother. It was difficult enough for her to be displaced and bounced around from one couch to another. 12 is old for a dog and change is no longer easy to adapt to. I have no doubt that had I given her away it would have killed her. She is an integral part of our family.

    This was the only sentiment I couldn’t take any wisdom from. But all others helped immensely. If you’ll accept my heartfelt gratitude, I’ll say good bye for now, and hope I can be of help to others in the future.

  24. maew says:

    I haven’t read the responses but I wonder…why does she have to give up custody? Can’t she sent her son for a while to live with her brother for a short period of time WITHOUTH giving up custody until she gets back on her feet? I remember that at some point where my mother was going through some major difficulties when I was 13 (we were living in another country where there were major political issues and the situation in the country was chaotic), she sent me to live with my Aunt for a few months until she was able to come back to this country and back on her feet. She never lose contact with me, she talked to me and I was big enough to understand that it was a safety concern, and all I though about was that my mother was trying to proctect.
    I don’t like the fact that the brother is not offering help to her too but I think she should speak with her son (he is 11 he is old enough to voice his opinion) and take his opinion into account, talk with her brother (why her son can’t stay with them for a little while without her giving custody), and maybe go to the same city and start immediately looking for a job.

  25. Larissa says:

    Twitter @
    I think she shouldn’t give up custody.If her brother really wants to help, he should loan her some money to rent a small apartment so she’ll be able to find a job and start things up again…but that’s only me….
    Larissa´s last blog ..Hair removal methodsMy ComLuv Profile

  26. Rachel Sarah says:

    @Larissa: Thanks for chiming in. The suggestion about asking for a loan from her family is a good one.

  27. Shannon says:

    Twitter @
    I don’t think she should give up custody or let her son move in with her brother and his family. I am a single mother of three children and I struggle daily myself. The one thing that keeps me going is my children. We have been through alot of struggles and I have not made the best decisions in the past. But no matter what I want my children with me. I don’t see a problem with the brother keeping him sometimes or visiting on weekends if he is willing to help. If you could live closer to your brother and his family that would be nice for both of you. But that is not always possible. Life is hard and I know you want what is best for your son. That being said, I think being with his Mom and having a bond or relationship with your brother is the way to go. Good luck and praying for you!!!

  28. lori says:

    Twitter @
    Yes, please give up custody! The child needs someone who puts him first, not 2nd to a “brand new boyfriend”. Go and be with him, make him happy- it is of course ALL about him! You can always have more children, but a real good boyfriend, only comes around every 15 mins or so…and he is obviously a real winner seeing as he accepts your life and isn’t trying to change it to meet his selfish wants, all at the sake of a sweet little boy. Why are you even struggling with this decision lady?! OBVIOUSLY, the right thing to do is put your boyfriend first and foremost while leaving your child in the background…I’m sure that years from now whenever your new man has already left you for someone else for convenient for his life, that you won’t regret this decision at all…I pray that whatever happens, you get exactly what you deserve. :)

We'd love to hear from YOU

CommentLuv Enabled