Can this relationship be saved?
by Dr. Leah
Filed under All, Featured, Single Moms
When we posted about a newly married single mom who felt overwhelmed by her husband’s lack of parenting participation, we expected you to question why this newly married guy was so resistant to helping with the kids. We knew that some of you would ask why this couple had NOT discussed their respective responsibilities BEFORE the marriage. After all, we’ve talked about the blended family challenges before.
When a new reader responded by sharing her situation, however, we were stunned. And we knew instantly that we had to continue this conversation.
Here’s what this married single mom told us:
“I’m now an official member of the ‘Never thought it would be me’ club,” she said sadly.
This married single mom was divorced seven years ago. Her ex husband was chronically physically abusive. The relationship ended the day that he hit her one-year-old baby for the first time.
When this single mom started dating a year later, “good father” was high on her priority list for many reasons, including the fact that the kids’ bio-dad had subsequently exited — permanently. And, after the typical relationship fumbles, she believed that she had met a single dad who was everything she could ever want in a father for her kids. She was very anxious to remarry.
Here’s what went wrong: This single mom perceived this guy as a devoted and caring father. What she did not realize (or ignored) was that he loved only his own kids — his love was nontransferable.
And here’s how things stand right now: Her husband demands total parental authority over her children. This single mom has no authority whatsoever with his teen-aged daughter and eleven year old son. Only her husband and his ex can make house rules or hand out consequences. Her husband has true joint custody so the kids live with their dad in her home every other week. As you might imagine, his kids can literally do NO wrong. Yet her kids — who are now fourteen and nine — are held to a strict standard. And they are expected to behave impeccably.
This married single mom is truly torn. This man is the only “father” her kids know. And her kids express a willingness to accept the status quo no matter how unfair just to keep the family together.
This married single mom believes, however, that this double standard is hurting her kids. And she believes that her husband’s “family rules” are unreasonable.
Hindsight is always 20-20. And there’s no turning back the clock. So, let’s focus on helping this married single mom look ahead.
Should she cut her losses and end this lop-sided relationship for her sake — AND for the kids?
Or, can this relationship be saved?
~~~
(Photo courtesy of RandomSandy)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
Related posts:
- When you’re married. And he won’t help with the kids. When we opened the conversation about married moms who feel like single moms, the torrent of heart breaking tales from...
- Rachel got married today This is Dr. Leah, blogging today from California today — where Rachel got married. After 10 years parenting solo, Rachel...
- Can a relationship with a parent do more harm than good? When we talked about “no show” co-parents, you enthusiastically agreed that a Plan B was essential. You told us that...
- Will our blended family make it? We heard from another single mom this week who has fallen in love with a single dad. Woot! And they...


Follow Singlemommyhood on Twitter




Twitter @ http://www.cathouseteri.blogspot.com
All children want things to remain status quo to keep the family together. They are not anywhere near mature enough to understand the implications of maintaining such an imbalanced household. In fact, I doubt that anyone in the household understands those implications.
It was nearly eleven years ago that I left my ex husband. Our relationship was very ill, but appeared to be just fine. Recently, I reminded my daughter of what she said to me at that time. She said, “Mom, can’t you just stay unhappy so we can remain a family? I mean everyone in a marriage is unhappy, right?” Her questions made me realize more than ever that now was the time to go. I had never meant for her to learn that concept and I certainly did not want to validate it any longer. She’s 25 now. And when I reminded her of this conversation of long ago, she said, “Mom, I often tell people what a shock and devastation it was to have my parents divorce. But I see now that it was the best thing to happen to any of us. I am so, so glad you did it.”
All three of my children feel this way. And my only regret is that I didn’t do it sooner.
Catty Gramma Teri´s last blog ..Easily Onward- Through Flowers and Weed
Twitter @ http://tsquest.blogspot.com
*sigh*
I have no words of advice. She HAS to speak up… she HAS to do what she thinks is right.
Though her situation is sad, sharing her story is really good for the rest of the single parent community.
Before you get married, DISCUSS, DISCUSS, DISCUSS!!!
Thank you for sharing this.
T´s last blog ..Secrets of the bride
Twitter @ BigLittleWolf
I don’t think any of us are in a position to advise her, with the bits and pieces we know.
Yes, every child wants the parents (they know) to stay together. And yes, this sounds dreadfully unfair, and must be terrible to life day in and day out, for this mom and her kids.
But does she have any sense of what sort of ex-husband he would be?
How old is she? Can she earn a living? Would she get any sort of support from him for her two children?
What might the aftermath of divorce be with this man?
Bad marriages are many. But a roof over your head, food on the table, medical and dental care, decent schools – if there is no violence and no verbal abuse – and she’s managed this situation all this time – what has changed? How might things change for the worse if they divorce?
I’m not saying they should stay together. I am saying she should weight the worst-case scenarios of staying married and divorcing, and see which is truly worse.
BigLittleWolf´s last blog ..Send me no flowers
If she’s thinking of leaving, she could tell him so, and tell him she’ll stay if he goes to counseling with her and the kids.
Twitter @ whitetrashmom80
This is yet another post that makes me mad at women who do not empower themselves. Children learn to imitate adults from a very early age, and if a women is subserviant to her husband like this then you are raising a son to be controlling and a daughter to accept a man to more important than herself.
I think women who lower their standards to be married, have a father for their children, want to be financially supported, etc. are setting their children up for failure. Those are your children, if he is not willing to co-parent with you then he is not a loving and suitable father for them. If she continues like this, her children will come to resent her as adults. No man has a right to take away your rights as a mother. Stand up for yourself and wake up.
Twitter @ lildevilmama
Hindsight is always 20/20 for sure!! One of my biggest regrets is not going to therapy with the Bio before we split and waiting until after we were in front of a judge to be forced to discuss the how/why our relationship wasn’t functioning. Had we put as much work into working on our relationship, as we have our co-parenting relationship today things may have turned out differently.
Just my thoughts, but maybe if someone outside the marriage can show him how unrealistic it is to have such a divided house then they can work towards a resolution.
Twitter @ http://www.cathouseteri.blogspot.com
I realize that no one is in a position ever to judge another household. And easy for us to sit here based on one little letter what’s going on there. But I spent years and years living in the limbo of being careful about advising people on whether or not to give up on a bad relationship. I spent years and years and years with people telling me that I should stay, because after all, he wasn’t beating the crap out of me or anything. He was a good man. A good provider. But the underlying control issues and the emotional abuse was being ignored by all. And once I decided to leave, I looked back and remembered all of the people who very lovingly and with good intentions said, “try to make it work… for the sake of everyone involved…” and I had a sudden urge to contact every one of them and say, “You know what? You suck.”
I left a very good living. To live like a pauper. And yes, it’s important to weigh the real issues that would involve leaving a bad situation. Again, easy for me to judge but this situation sounds like more than just a bad situation. We get into things because we felt insecure. We find a man we think will provide security. And then we don’t know what to do because we need that security, as big or small as it is.
Still, the power really must come from within. Regardless of whether we choose to stay or go.
Catty Gramma Teri´s last blog ..Easily Onward- Through Flowers and Weed
It kind of blows me away when I read posts like: “the husband and ex gets to decide the rules of the new household”. Says who ?!
The husband and ex ?
Um, no!
The husband and ex can decide how they’d like things to be, regarding their children, with equal input from the new spouse(s). But, the husband and ex trying to dictate to the mom how things will be regarding her children is utterly ridiculous.
I agree with the poster that said the mom needs to take back her power, and the mom needs to hold on to her power in that situation.
Sounds like it’s time for the mom to negotiate a new *fair* agreement in her marriage, and it’s probably not going to be comfortable for all of the adults involved. But, it is necessary, because her children are not being treated fairly, and that’s not okay.
As their mom, it is her job & responsibility to set the tone for how her children deserve to be treated.
The house rules need to be set by her & her husband (the ex can decide how things will run in her house), and the house rules need to apply to ALL of the kids equally, not just her kids.
Maybe mom was so desperate/eager/thankful to have a spouse and/or father figure for her children, that she’s allowing her gratitude for her husband being a father figure to her children overshadow the reality of what kind of father figure he’s actually being to her kids.
Her husband doesn’t need to love her children, however he does need to treat her children with respect, kindness and fairness, and he’s failing miserably. She’s also failing to protect her kids from being treated poorly, and it’s also doing the stepkids a disservice to grow up thinking they’re above others. The stepkids are going to grow up with entitlement issues, and if you’ve met anyone with entitlement issues, it’s pretty obvious they’re not enjoyable type of people to be around.
Twitter @ notthecar
I want to know what changed as well. She has been with him 12 years and just now she wants out?
Also just because he provides doesn’t mean it’s worth staying. Too many women underestimate their ability to take care of themselves and marry out of desperation and stay married out of fear. Trapped is not something your marriage should become.
Kia´s last blog ..NotTheCar- @loneriderbeer I was at Durham last night the waiter said he thought apex only
Twitter @ SugarJones
Sounds like this woman moved too quickly and ended up in another abusive relationship. It happens to women prone to abuse all the time. It happened to me, too. I had a physically abusive husband… then had a controlling and verbally abusive husband. The second seemed perfect at first, but then our first child together came and everything changed. After eight years of trying to make things work, I’m getting divorced.
For the mom in this situation, I have complete empathy and hope things work out. Counseling, group therapy, independent activities all help to give you strength to speak up and do what’s right, whether that’s demanding that your husband treat the kids and you more fairly or, if necessary, leaving.
Sugar Jones´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – Trees
Twitter @ leiamom72
Well, I’m not quite sure where to begin. I guess, with thank you to all who have responded. Whether angry, empathetic, confused or thinking I’m just a doormat, all opinions are highly regarded.
Of all the things I have learned throughout college, marriage, divorce, parenting and life in general, is that the truth always lies somewhere in the middle. Even then, everyones middle is different.
Let me clear up some facts first.
I am 38 yrs old, my husband is 47. I have been married to my husband for 5 years this October. We dated exclusively for two. We never shared a home before marrying. We didn’t have “sleepovers” and we dated for 8 months before introducing each other to our respective children.
Please bear w me. This is one of the most difficult decisions I have made in all of my life. Ironically, when I left my first husband, I was a very liberating and empowering experience. I had been abused in EVERY way for years. We were very young when married. I dropped out of med school, still in undergrad at the time we were married, to move to another state as my ex was in the military. I have come to believe that the only reason I didn’t leave, or was married in the first place, was total and complete fear. Fear of my husband, being alone, in a foreign country…that list goes on. Sadly, I knew exactly what I was getting into with him from the very beginning. That is a whole different blog! Proudly, however, I can say with confidence that after some fantastic therapy, I recognized my personality traits that lead me into that marriage.
Back on track. So the difference now, is that I still do not fully understand how I ended up in this sad place with a man whom I believed loved me AND MY KIDS.
I do know that there were many red flags in the beginning. Please, I do ask that your responses to the following be from your heart but with your heart also.
Red flags
After about 6 months of dating, I requested that my husband please remove his ex wifes clothes from his closet that she had left behind. The first few times, he would just blow it off. Tell me he would get around to it. Finally, I was frustrated enough that I asked him to please explain why he wouldn’t get rid of them. He said,”They don’t bother me. They are meaningless.” Then the last and final time I asked, his response was, “you are so selfish! What do you want me to do?? Take them out to the garage where my kids will see their mothers clothes in a trash bag?!”. Well, I felt exactly how he told me I was. Selfish. How could I be so insensitive?? I let it go, for awhile. One more try. It ended up in a complete blowout with him screaming that I just nag him and nag him until I get my way…….selfish again. Guilt. Self-doubt. That was the night the spiral down started.
When I get to the part about the b-day party, if you’re not grinding your teeth in frustration at my blinders now, you will be……:(
Mother duty calls, more tomorrow.
Love and thanks,
Leiamom
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
He sounds kinda manipulative and controling to me. Maybe not physically abusive, but if he twists everything you want (and removing clothes from his closet that aren’t yours or his seems reasonable to me) into you being a selfish, unreasonable nag, that’s abuse. To have your own wants, needs, desires and opinions made subordinant to his is wrong.
I’d leave. But that’s just me.
alley´s last blog ..Is there a line
Twitter @ http://cnsmithauthor1.wordpress.com
When we are faced with situations like these in our lives (tough ones), we have to go back and look at the decisions that led us to this point. We are all responsible for the choices we make and this lady said that she “was very anxious” to remarry, but look at what it is costing her. Does she believe that she is worthy of respect and what she REALLY WANTS IN A MARRIAGE? I agree that is is time for her to take back her power. She can start doing that by loving herself. One way to do that is to set loving boundaries with others and learning how to say, “no.” Well for someone that has been giving her power away in her previous relationship and now her current one, she’s going to need help.
I recommend getting the book, “I Can Do It: How To Use Affirmations To Change Your Life”. By Louise L. Hay it comes with a companion CD so you can listen to it in the car.
This CD has worked miracles in my life. I was involved in a physically abusive relationship for 10 years then I went from that into one with a married man becuase my self worth was so LOW at that point. This relationship produced my son. However, I started to heal my old wounds and become more empowered. I literally woke up one day and made the decision to walk away from this relationship. It was very scary because I was trying to have some sense of a “family” for my son. It was all built on a false and shaky foundation.
All I am saying is just take a look at this really, even if it’s extremely painful. It is possible for you to get the love and relationship you really want, but it will take you to start making choices that really serve you.
If after looking at “this”, you really feel in your heart that you should leave, get things in order for you and your kids and do it!
I’m not saying it will be easy, I had challenges, my financial situation suffered a bit after I left. That pales in comparison to how liberated I feel in taking my power and self-respect back.
Twitter @ swatibharteey
Oh I am so very sorry to hear this; I am assuming you have already talked to him about the imbalance and he disagrees/won’t change his behavior.
My view is that it’s time to go and I feel really sad saying that. But imagine ten years passing and your kids ending up in relationships where someone is mistreating them because they themselves allow it or they think it’s normal – it’ll break your heart even more.
You’ll be ok – you are obviously a strong woman for leaving your 1st husband – better to single with kids in a happy, respectful, loving home than married with all that horrible stuff going on.
You and your kids will be able to form your own relationship – and you’ll find a new inner strength together.
Good luck – Swati
Swati´s last blog ..I Have a Confession to Make
Twitter @ swatibharteey
p.s. You are not selfish. You are a strong woman who fell in love – it happens to everybody. Look forward, not back, and change the future for your kids and yourself.
Swati
Swati´s last blog ..I Have a Confession to Make
Twitter @ http://tsquest.blogspot.com
It sounds like she went from one type of abuse to another.
It is STILL abuse. You do have a right to have a mind of your own… and wishes and requests that should be considered. If he is downright calling you names because you speak up, then he’s doing the same to your children. Is that the way you want your children to be treated?
More than that, is that the way YOU want to be treated? This all starts with you. Kids are “resilient” and all that but they do look for relationships that model what they saw as a child. It’s all that they know.
But YOU? YOU have to take care of YOU. The rest will fall into place.
T´s last blog ..To love is to be vulnerable
First off, I hope my post didn’t come across as harsh. If it did, I apologize. The last thing you need is to reach out for help, and have virtual strangers bashing you.
Your situation struck a cord with me, because I too broke free from an unhealthy relationship (we married young as well, had kids, and things snowballed from there).
You should be proud of yourself for breaking free from your first marriage!!
Abusers are big on saying a woman is “selfish, a nag, controlling, etc” that’s how they emotional keep you in check.
I would recommend reading a book on Boundaries by Henry Cloud, John Townsend. They have some really helpful books.
There was nothing wreong with you requesting he remove his exes clothing from the closet. There is something wrong with him wanting to keep them (is he emotionally over his ex?). He doesn’t need to throw them away in the trash. The clothes can be returned to his ex, donated to a shelter, or bagged up in a black garbage bag and discreetly thrown away without the kids even knowing. So, his excuse was very flimsy.
I agree that it sounds like you’re in another abusive relationship. And I’d hate to think you’d settle for being bullied every time you use your voice in your marriage. That’s not healthy for you, or your kids.
I think a lot of parents long to raise their kids in a more structured family environment and that can sometimes cloud their judgment. Love can cloud our judgment too (my mom’s been married 5 times, and they all turned out to be jerks!).
What steps are you going to take to turn this situation around for you & your kids?
Marital counseling is a good place to start. If he’s not willing to attend counseling, and improve things so both of you can be happy, and the family overall can be a more healthy, sound, and high functioning family, I personally would not be willing to invest anymore of my heart, time or energy into being married to him. And the kids don’t need to grow up watching you be treated poorly and they don’t deserve to be treated unfairly either.
You can’t fix this on your own. You can’t carry the whole weight of the marriage on your back. He has to be willing to do his share of the work too.
Good luck !
Twitter @ leiamom72
Good afternoon everyone! Wow, i cant tell you how much it means to me that so many, I know its relative…but, of you have responded!!
Lets get right to it as I dont have much time, again…
First, let me address the whole therapy issue. We have been in marriage counseling TWICE. The first time, i dont think either of us were ready to be honest with ourselves let alone each other.
The last time, was a doozy. I can get into details later. What started out as marriage counseling for the both of us, ended up three years later with me sitting alone at a table in the intensive unit (locked-down) of the psychiatric hospital in a nearby city. I had decided, on my own, if I didnt take that step I might not be there tomorrow to kiss my babies goodnight. What led up to that was, in the only word I can think to use, Hell.
I believe, with all of my heart and soul, that I had allowed my husband to emotionally rape me to the extent that I had become addicted to painkllers, very addicted, to self-medicate my depression. I knew full well the dangers, I have been a nurse for years. Still, it didnt stop me from using them to break free from the real world to go on another day. To those who have never suffered from addiction or depression, Im sure your first thought will be, “How can she say she loves her children and do that to herself?”. You know what, there is a HUGE part of me that asks myself that same question every day. But when I was in the middle of Hell, it was the only way I felt like could function from day-to-day. Again, that is another whole story.
While my husband and I were in counseling together, I just became more and more frustrated and depressed because he would answer questions in just the right way that our therapist thought we were making progress. Honestly, I dont think he did this intentionally to manipulate the situation. I truly believe that he thought he was really putting ALOT of effort into it. I would bring up an issue, like the clothes. the therapist would say, “why did you respond that way, *John*?” He would say he really didnt know. He really was afraid that his kids would see the clothes somewhere and be hurt. I realize years later how ridiculous that excuse sounds. Still the same, it worked. The therapist would say, blah blah, you need to respect her feeling blah blah. He would say your right I should….I’m sorry. AND THAT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE IT IN HIS MIND. After those words, we were to never discuss it again. If i did, nag was where it ended up. So, years of that, lead to me having a complete emotional break. Do I assume responsibility for my actions and the choices I made?? Absolutely! But, my husband will never admit that he had some responsibility, as my husband, to protect my feelings. Not use them as a doormat to wipe his muddy feet on…….
BTW, before I close for now, I want to tell you all it has taken me such a long time to get through the responses. They touch me so deeply I cry for about 30 minutes after reading each one. I pray that you will all stay with me through this. I need, yes need, your opinions. It is so easy for my judgement to be cloudy and biased now. I appreciate all of your advice, support and occassional kick in the butt:)
More later,
leiamom
Twitter @ http://www.teresaandkids.com
I think it’s impossible for any outsider to say whether you should stay or go. It’s up to you. But I will give you the same advice I give practically everyone, including myself… if this were your sister and your best friend, what would you tell her to do?
For me, trying to take my own feelings and hurt out of the decision-making process helps me to look at things objectively. Pros and cons lists are helpful, too.
Folks here have some great advice and I agree with many that say you have to remember who is important her–you and your kids. What messages does this send to your kids? How will they look at relationships now? Does this make you happy?
I’m a big believer in the idea that I don’t need a man in my life unless he is making it better. Things are hard enough without one who makes my load a little lighter.
I hope you’re able to process all of this, maybe get some counseling and make things better for your family soon.
Teresa Coates´s last blog ..another chapter down
Twitter @ http://www.cathouseteri.blogspot.com
leiamom,
I’m sure it is the hope of everyone here that you feel supported through this. My ex and I certainly went down the road of the counseling and the same thing happened. The therapist calmly said blah blah blah and then the ex would say “…well she never this and she’s never that…” (one funny thing he said was, “Most women hate the way they are and she never says that about herself. Can you imagine having to live with someone like that?”)and the therapist would say “how did that make you feel?” and finally I said to the therapist and the ex, “If you don’t have something new to offer… something with life in it… I’m not interested in what you’re selling because this is the same old dead thing.”
Indeed this is your decision and you and your children will live out the results of the choice you make. But I fully believe that every person who has commented here respects and admires you and feel strongly that you should be living in a relationship where you are respected and admired ever so much more than you have been. I’m sure you know this. You feel it every time he demeans you that you don’t deserve this. But until you stand up and say it and believe it, nothing will change. Any one of us would love to ride up and rescue you but it has to come from you.
Please feel free to ask for any kind of support that you think would help. I know there are many generous hearts here who would feel privileged to give it.
Catty Gramma Teri´s last blog ..Easily Onward- Through Flowers and Weed
Twitter @ leiamom72
The more I think about what my step daughter said, the more upset I become. Not sad, but angry. While I understand that she also has gone through some of this too, I think about how we all have to walk on eggshells when my stepkids are here. The more I think, the more I see how much my girls HAVE been through. They don’t leave every other week. They are here thick and thin. So, then explain to me why then, they (my girls) don’t want to see the family split?
I believe that my stepkids are the stereotypical entitlement minded kids. This is the fault of not just their parents, but their entire family operates in this mode of the sun rises and sets by those two kids. I would question this opinion if it were only my own. But, almost anyone that knows them, friend or foe, would tell you its an almost obssessive relationship.
In my next “installment” is the tale of the overnight bday party that almost killed me…because I wasn’t allowed to come.
Leiamom
Twitter @ leiamom72
If that last post didn’t make sense, I think somewhere in cyberspace a post is missing..yikes! It was long! I will wait to c if it pops up…
Leiamom
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
It sounds like you know what you need to do. I think the kids don’t want to see things change because they are young and would rather deal with the issues they know than the unknown.
But self respect is a hard thing to teach. Lead by example. Demand better for yourself and your kids, and follow through when he doesn’t want to give it.
alley´s last blog ..Mommy competitivness
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
It sounds like you know what you need to do. I think the kids don’t want to see things change because they are young and would rather deal with the issues they know than the unknown.
But self respect is a hard thing to teach. Lead by example. Demand better for yourself and your kids, and follow through when he doesn’t want to give it.
Twitter @ leiamom72
PLEEEEEEASE, don’t go away yet! I know many of you may feel like there might not be any more advice you can give than what you already have. Nothing could be further than the truth. Even if its something that has been said a thousand times, sometimes its #1,001 that sinks in….
Leiamom
Twitter @ http://www.cathouseteri.blogspot.com
Can’t speak for everyone but I’m here.
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
I really can’t add anything that I haven’t said earlier here, or on other posts. You have to be willing to set the parameters of what you will or will not put up with.
Will leaveing him be hard? Probably. I left my ex with two suitcases, two sons and another on the way. i lived on my dad’s couch for six months and it took years before I felt like I had much going for me, but it was still better than being with someone who had threatened to kill me, isolated me from my friends and family, and involved me in crime against my wishes and good sense.
alley´s last blog ..Small Town Friday night
Twitter @ angi33
I hope you can find the strength to advocate for your children. I hope he can find the love that brought you together to realize that it’s best for all of you to find a middle ground. It’s SO hard to co-parent. It’s SO hard to make the right decision, but it’s harder to realize that the right decision is not easy to know, understand or decipher in most cases. No one can tell you if you should leave him or stay and work something out, other than you. We all want to tell you what’s best, but without living your life…how can we know. What does your family say? What do they see? What do your friends say? I hope your family can find peace.
angi´s last blog ..The Regret of Divorce
Twitter @ /
@Angi: Thanks so much for your comment. We’ve just started to read your blog and your latest entry (“The Regret of Divorce”) has touched us.