When the school wants a “family” picture
by Dr. Leah
Filed under All, Featured, Single Moms
By now, you’re fairly settled into your kids’ school routines, yes? Those pesky school forms are finally turned in. And most of you have figured out a workable homework schedule — which is always a tricky part of the return to school challenge. As solo parents, we understand that juggling work responsibilities with overseeing the kids’ homework is a constant struggle.
Also, both of us have coped (not always successfully) with homework assignments about “family.” Whether kids are asked to depict their family tree or draw a picture of their family, such assignments can make even the most confident single parent cringe — especially if you’re still working through your own feelings about the end of a relationship, or adjusting to the relentless demands of a solo parent or a choice mom.
So, when we received this email from a single mom with a daughter in kindergarten, we sympathized. Here’s what this single mom told us:
“I’m a divorced single mom. My ex and I broke up when I was six months pregnant. Since then, he has chosen to have little involvement with our daughter, ” she explained.
Apparently, her ex has since remarried and his new wife is pushing him to have some involvement with his daughter. But, he’s in arrears in child support. And he manages to see his daughter only once or twice a year. (This single mom makes a home with her mother.)
At first, the kindergarten homework assignment to draw a picture of your family was no big deal. Featuring herself with pink barrettes and the family dog wearing shoes, this little girl drew her mom and grandmother.
“I was not surprised that she left out her dad since we tackled the “where’s my dad” questions as soon as she started day care,” she told us candidly. “After all, he’s chosen not to be part of his child’s life.”
Here’s what did surprise this single mom: Her daughter’s teacher contacted this mom and asked to meet for a conference. The teacher seemed distraught that this bio-dad had been omitted from this family picture. When this single mom offered a bare bones explanation of her family circumstances, the teacher pressed for more information, citing her need to know as much as possible about the lives of her students outside of school. This teacher went on to tells this mom she needed more details — and would like to follow up.
This single mom tells us that she’s uncertain about what to do. She wonders if the teacher’s curiosity about her family isn’t really a bit out of bounds.
So, this single mom is anxious to ask YOU …
Are these teacher questions about the missing bio-dad too probing?
If yes, what’s your guess about what’s really motivating all the curiosity?
What’s your advice for handling questions about your family that you’d prefer NOT to answer?
(Photo via Flickr:JessicaKathryn)
|
Ultimate go-to guide for single mothers. The Complete Single Mother is the only comprehensive and best selling self help book ever written for single parents. It’s packed with savvy advice, sisterly comfort, as well as reassuring answers to all your single mom challenges. |
|
Read the book! Single Mom Seeking is a tell-all about how to date and remain a dedicated and involved parent. It’s a spunky, sexy, and moving chronicle of the humor, pitfalls, and rewards of balancing it all — single-mom style. |
No related posts.






Twitter @ notthecar
In a word yes the teacher is asking too much. The mom has already explained dad doesn’t live with them there’s no more to discuss.
I think the teacher is trying to pry for no reason other then personal curiosity. The most extensive questions I’ve ever gotten about my ex was from the school psychologist. Never a teacher. In fact my daughter had a kindergarten teacher who sent home notes around mothers day and fathers day to the whole class asking if there would be a problem making crafts and if they wanted grandparents subbed for mom and dad to reduce stress. I was not the only single mom in the class but I was definitely in the minority. I think I just had a more aware of family dynamics teacher.
Now it’s almost status quo for the school to have custody papers on file to prevent abductions.
Twitter @ http://www.vomitcomit.wordpress.com
None of her business. I’d be furious if I were harassed like that.
Thordora´s last blog ..The Break Up
Twitter @ solomother
Geez. As if being a single mom isn’t hard enough.
I’d tell this teacher my daughter’s father chose not to be in the picture, and any more attempts on the teacher’s part to ‘understand’ will only serve to upset my child, who might begin to feel inadequate or weird for not having the requisite ‘dad’ to draw.
It’s much more polite than what I’d want to say, which is something along the lines of, “Back off, B#tch!”
My children are now in their early 20s. My son had learning difficulties and often baffled his teachers. It was not uncommon for them to ask a variety of questions that I considered inappropriate (school social workers were worse). Often I did not consider the teachers to be particularly intelligent or educated. It’s just a fact of life: unless you home school you will encounter teachers who are nosy, interfering, bored, and even malicious. Sad but true.
Twitter @ eatdrinkdivorce
AArrgghh! This teacher is out of line on so many levels. The mother has given an explanation AND THAT’S ENOUGH! The teacher is being a bully. Seriously. The mother ought to have a conversation with the principal, so that this teacher does not continue with this line of inappropriate badgering with any other parent.
I hope this parent doesn’t let this teacher push her around. I hope the parent stands her ground and lets this teacher know that she will not tolerate disrepect.
Lovebabz´s last blog ..CEREAL FOR LUNCH
Twitter @ http://semanticallydriven.com
I agree with what the others said, the teacher’s being too nosy. Maybe she thinks the dad’s being cut out of the picture unnecessarily? I don’t know, but the mum should only divulge what she’s comfortable with. I’ve never been hassled for information like this.
Twitter @ teresa_coates
If I were her, I’d be angry about the questioning. I can see the teacher being a little concerned if someone was purposely left out of the picture (i.e.. mad at dad, so he’s not “family” today). But if she knows that the family situation is that the child lives with Mom and Grandma, then that’s all there should be to it.
My concern now would be how that teacher is going to react to their family situation. Does she think it’s inappropriate? Will she continue to point out how some kids don’t have fathers who love them? Oh yeah, I’ve heard that one before.
I think it’s good for the teacher to know what the family situation is, but to know more than the basic facts is unnecessary and incredibly rude of her to push it.
We solo parents need to stand strong and proud because dammit, we’re doing the best we can. Some of us are completely on our own and doing all we can. There’s no shame in that, no matter what that teacher may think.
Teresa Coates´s last blog ..another chapter down
Twitter @ mackiefried
I differ slightly with the others. Teachers need to have good insight into a child’s homelife purely so that if ever problem behaviour rears its ugly head she is already aware of the home situation and, hopefully, able to assess accurately whether that is causing the behaviour. Our kids tell teachers everything anyway. Haven’t we all heard the story about: T: What does your daddy call your mommy? C: B*&%$. Whether there is an absent father, a same-sex couple or, as in my case, white parents with a black child, the teacher needs to understand where problems could be coming from. Thought-provoking article. What do you think, being the experts?
Catherine Mackie´s last blog ..Big Five
Twitter @ http://scribblingsofasoccermom.com
I agree. Giving some information to the teacher is completely appropriate so the teacher doesn’t worry about excluding anyone or including anyone who shouldn’t be included, i.e. bio dad. I start every school year with the same speech: their parents don’t live together, are divorced and remarried, but you can contact either of us for any reason and the other will immediately know. We share joint physical custody and talk all the time about the children…there is no animosity.
I want the teachers to feel comfortable calling/emailing or sending notes to either of us and that everyone will be notified. I don’t need to tell them oh, btw he cheated with the woman he’s now married to…I mean seriously keep the nose out of the details! Overview appropriate, beyond that is pure curiosity and we all know how that worked out for the cat!
Soccer Mom´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday- Then
Diane: Thanks for chiming in. We always love to hear from parents who are on the “other side” of parenting.
Information is fine, but sounds like the teacher is making this into an issue where there isn’t one. Just wait, at the first sign of behaviour problems in class (that all children have at some point) this same teacher will be pointing to the lack of a father figure.
Honestly though, when I saw the picture above I thought we were going to be talking about a child with two mothers and a teacher being “worried” about a student being raised by gay parents.
Whatever the family situation, the teacher should not push for more info than the parents give. And the mom shouldn’t offer it unless a situation arises that warrants it.
My line for teachers is this “He has a positive yet limited relationship with his father.” Enough said.
Wow I am so shocked! In this day and age with so many different types of families out there I am so surprised with this teacher. My daughter started kindergarten this year and was asked to draw our family. She drew herself, both cats and myself. Not once did I hear from the teacher about where is dad or anything. Now when I filled out ALL the paperwork for the school I put N/A where is asked for father information. My daughter is adopted and doesn’t have one since I did a single adoption. Now I have had people ask about a dad and have said not in the picture, doesn’t have one, etc and no one has pushed me about it.
This teacher might have reasons for asking about the dad but is sounds as if she hasn’t voiced them. Maybe this child has talked about her father in school and the teacher was surprised not to see it in the family drawing, if that is the case she should have been clear with mom about it. If she wants to know just to know then I would be asking her to back off.
Twitter @ ohthatmomma
How dare that teacher ask anything of the nature as it pertains to the child’s family? First and foremost it is not her business. She doesn’t need to know the details of anyone’s family life. How about she share the details of her life with the parents. Aren’t the parents privy to that information since she is teaching their children?
This is why I don’t allow my children to participate in things that require them to write about their families, such as:
What was the worst thing your mom or dad every did or said to you? How did that make you feel?
What did you have for dinner last night, and if you could have anything you want for dinner what would it be?
See, questions like this are to pry into your business.
NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS!
Aside from my initial reaction of irritation, I thought the following:
1) Was the lack of a dad portrayed the only thing that prompted the teacher to ask for a conference with the mother? If so, that would give me immediate pause – because with all the paperwork involved in entering school, the teacher should have been knowledgeable about the child’s home living situation – at least the basics. And if there wasn’t a behavior that coincided the drawing I don’t understand the need for the conference in the first place – families come in all shapes and sizes for all sorts of reasons (someone should buy this teacher a couple of Todd Parr books).
2) I also thought – is this someone new to the profession? If so the eagerness/ignorance might lie there. In an effort to do well/right by the child this teacher stepped over boundaries.
3) I think the teachers desire to pursue the issue (especially if it is based solely off the drawing) would cause me to talk to the principal and perhaps go so far as to remove my child from the class. Extreme – perhaps, but I think at that age and in this crucial transition period for children having an environment where they are accepted and not isolated out for differences is important. If the drawing is the sole basis for the action, I think it telegraphs a teacher who is ill-equiped to accept a child’s life for what it is. I can understand Diane’s point about the ignorance and unfairness kids have to face when navigating teachers at school, I just feel like in kindergarten there is a lifetime ahead of them to learn about ignorance and ill-intended adults.
Twitter @ msjennixoxo
The teacher is definitely being too nosy. I’d be pretty irritated if I had just explained the situation, and the teacher was asking for more information on the subject. WHY does she need to know specifics? That would have been my question to her.
As for the follow up? If she requested it in the future, I would tell her I didn’t find a need to discuss my daughter’s family life any further.. that she knew what she needed to know. And if the teacher put up a fuss, I would be more than happy to include the principal in on the conversation.
Skylar just started kindergarten this year. In her family drawings in class, her dad has been included. But for one of her first show-n-tells, she had to bring a picture of her family to class. That picture consisted of me, herself, and her sister. There are several single parent children in Skylar’s class.. her teacher didn’t feel the need to question Skylar’s photo at all.
At the beginning of the year, the parents were asked to write a letter to the teacher.. so the teacher could learn more about her students. I of course mentioned in my letter, that we had just relocated to California, and that my ex was still in Washington DC. When our first parent teacher conference came around, it was brought up briefly. She just wanted to know whether or not their dad intended to visit them – which I was comfortable answering. I’m sure she was just curious, in case there was emotional upset with Skylar at any time of the year.
Anyway! Teacher is stepping out of line. And I would make it clear to her, that that’s how I felt.
Jenni´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – Sand Art & Mermaids
Twitter @ momma_sunshine
The teacher is definitely asking for too much information. It’s info that she simply doesn’t need to know. I would gently, but FIRMLY! tell the teacher that you’ve discussed this as much as you feel comfortable and that you would prefer to leave it at that.
I have no idea what is motivating all these questions from the teacher, but in my opinion, it’s completely inappropriate.
Momma Sunshine´s last blog ..Coping with Guilt
Twitter @ rodliberal
It amazes me the assumption by most here about the teacher’s motivation.
Our kids spend a big part of their lives in the care of a teacher. Growing up in Brazil, teachers are seen as an extension of your family in terms of care.
I don’t know if this teacher is just being nosy or genuinely curious about the girl’s family structure, but I think that needs to be determined before any judgment can be hurled at this person. Who knows? Maybe the girl has mentioned certain things to her teacher that she hasn’t to her mom about her dad being gone. Maybe not.
I openly talk about my family’s dynamics with my boys’ teacher now that we’ve got to know her for the past 2 years (2 kids under her care) and she’s very helpful in keeping us up to date on any issues or concerns our boys may be facing while we’re not around.
Dad of 3: You certainly bring a different perspective to this conversation. And we thank you for sharing your experiences with your boys’ teachers. Sounds like your kids are blessed with caring and involved teachers. We hope you visit us again soon.
Twitter @ rodliberal
I follow you on twitter and really enjoy your posts. Thanks for covering such great topics.
Unbelievable. It’s sad to say, but broken families are so common now as well as blended families – the teacher needs to adjust to the times and not make a hard situation even worse. Personally, I would have taken this further ( after the initial shock factor) – I’m wondering whether this is a private or catholic school, rather than the public system??
Twitter @ http://gawlas.blogspot.com
I’m a teacher and I am telling you, that teacher is out of line. It is not her business what configuration the student’s family is. This is the 21st century and kids with divorced parents, kids who don’t know one parent or the other, kids who’ve spent so much time in foster care that they don’t know who their parents are, kids who are raised by grandparents, and kids who are being raised by siblings are all “normal”.
This teacher is looking for “dirt” and the mom needs to contact the school principal about it.
I wish they offered “your rights as a parent of a public school student” classes for parents, I really do.
Just to be clear, you don’t have to tell them anything.
alley´s last blog ..Sigh – Again
My son wasn’t diagnosed with Asperger’s until the end of his 5th grade. Before then I normally would take the initiative and try to meet the teachers and staff before school started to talk to them about my son, his antics, and discuss what we were doing as far as therapies were concerned. It is very possible that this teacher just doesn’t understand the questions she is asking and their connotations.
If she wants to understand and learn more about single parenting, what the home life can be like, and the challenges that are faced, the I recommend you give her this great website called wwww.singlemommyhood.com.
It could be that the teacher has a counseling background and sees some traits that might need attention too, but she really should refer you to the school counselor if that was the case. Kids say THE DARNDEST things and it could be that your daughter said something that tripped a trigger for the teacher and she is trying to put it into perspective.
All that being said, my first reaction from the description above is pretty much the same as everyone else….it comes across as though she is stepping over a line, being condescending, and judgmental.
It used to exasperate me when people would hear about the issues my son was having and offer “fixes” for them…as if I was just meandering along not doing anything when the reality was that I had already implemented everything they could think of in a week times about 1000. They either didn’t believe me, or tried to tell me I was doing it wrong. It sounds bad, but mostly these people were trying to help. I would like to think this teacher is doing the same, just trying to help and it could be coming out wrong.
Crazy Computer Dad´s last blog ..An exercise you should do
Twitter @ jennsplace
It definitely comes across as the teacher being nosy. I don’t see why she would need more info than what was given from the picture drawn. If there’s a bigger concern then the school counselor or principal would be involved. I haven’t had this happen yet, and the school my son attends is definitely filled with ‘traditional’ families. I know this because the mail from the school has my ex-husband’s name on it – even though the paperwork shows him as secondary emergency contact only. I’ve called to change it and it’s not. Anyway, I do plan to touch on our situation briefly at parent/teacher conferences, but otherwise it’s not going to be the focus nor are dirty details going to be given either. The only reason I’m doing even that is because he told the teacher about his dad visiting from out of state recently. My point being is that if there aren’t any behavior issues or reason to give more info, don’t.
I, too, am a teacher and find this unusual. A simple explanation like the mom gave should be enough, and even that should be unnecessary. I might ask for a conference with the principal and the teacher to discuss the issue, and find out why the teacher called the conference in the first place.
@Diane: I hope you do not consider all or even a majority of teachers to be that way, because I think it’s not as common as you imply.
Twitter @ http://raregemsblog.wordpress.com/
My daughter’s father passed away when I was pregnant with her. I have found that instead of facing the questioning later, it’s better just to tell her teachers up front that her father passed away and that we don’t talk about him (she has severe disabilities and doesn’t understand death yet). I don’t like doing this in a face-to-face conversation because the result is usually looks of pity and “I’m sorry” which I don’t need. So I send her teachers an email stating simply, “her dad passed away before she was born and we don’t talk about him” before school starts and it has worked well and they’ve been very understanding. Maybe going forward this mom can simply send an email or note before school starts giving the simple explanation that dad isn’t involved and that he is not to be discussed. In this day and age, there are so many different kinds of families — 2 mommies, 2 daddies, one mommy, one daddy — that is just ridiculous for the teacher not to accept the simple explanation and follow the parent’s instructions for how the situation should be handled! If it continues, I’d be in the principal’s office!
Angie´s last blog ..Beatitudes for Disabled People
Angie: We appreciate your thoughtful comment and excellent advice. Thank you for adding to this important conversation. Please visit us again soon. (Peeked at your blog. Your little girl is a real charmer.)
Twitter @ ohthatmomma
When questions arise, and they will, my children know that they are not to tell anyone anything, PERIOD! They are to say, “You will have to ask my mom.” PERIOD! A few times I have received a few calls regarding this-and-that, I calmly, but firmly say, “That is personal and has no place with the teacher who is supposedly educating my child. I am sure you understand?!” Usually, that stops the nonsense!
How obnoxious of this teacher! I’d like to think that a good school teacher is intuitive, in this case, apparently not. What I mean is, if the teacher has concerns that the kid is not cared for because of her prejudices of single-parent families, then she should be using her natural or learned powers of observation of the child in the classroom. If she senses a cause for concern beyond a child’s colouring, then she should pursue the issue. Otherwise she should ask the question once, get the answer, and leave be!
Perhaps, having read some comments on here, our experiences as single parents lead us to automatically be defensive – we’ve put up a wall so as to protect our kids and ourselves from those who tend to judge. While I do think this particular teacher took this too far, perhaps her intentions weren’t merely to be nosy. When you drop the wall of defense and own the situation, you take the power away from their judgements..
Twitter @ http://raregemsblog.wordpress.com/
Thanks for taking a peek at my blog, Dr. Leah. I love your blog and only wish I’d found it sooner — so don’t worry, I’ll be back!
Twitter @ singlemomchrons
I’m really shocked at the teacher pressing so hard – usually they are experienced and savvy enough to know that if a child leaves a parent out, there has got to be a BIG reason. I think if you feel she treats your child any differently or keeps hounding you, I’d talk to the principal about moving her to a different classroom.
Swati
Twitter @ http://www.secondchancemoon.com
Does the teacher live under a rock? Seriously why would she call a conference because only mom and grandma were in the picture? It doesnt make sense to me. If I were the mom, I would nicely tell the teacher that she need not be concerned with the family drawing.
Nothing surprises me anymore.
My husband died when my youngets was 5. She was in Kindergarten in a day care center at that time. Those loving people had known us for 9+ years at that point – since my oldest was 3 – and they were the most supportive and wonderful poeple at the most difficult time in my life.
The public school was a whole other story. The things my oldest went through that year were just awful.
Then my little one went to first grade. We got through the year ok until we got to Father’s Day. This teacher had 6 Father’s day projects she wanted to do. She called me specially to find out how to handle it with my little one. Since I have been coached to follow my children’s lead, I asked my little one what she wanted to do. She wanted nothting to do with Father’s Day projects. I got ANOTHER call from the teacher about it and why my daughter didn’t want to do these SIX projects for some other family member. Duh.
There was some interesting prying in 2nd grade when my little one reacted strongly to her grandfather’s death. That was a challenge too.
I cry when I think about it.
This year our latest challenge is a “life timelime” for my little one for “health class.” Not just one family picture – one for each year of her life. I “so enjoyed” the stark family difference after her father died. This stuff is hard. It is actually sometimes harder to tell them to mind their own business then it is to just do the assignment. But then – I only know the minefields of widowhood and the death of a spouse/parent – not the minefield of divorce.
Hang in there everyone. It’s supposed to get better….
Oh – and I always inform teachers up front about our situation as well. It’s best for us that way.
Unlike Anghie’s situation, we talk about my husband. My girls and I have wonderful memories of him. He was a great husband and Dad. People are still amazingly insensitive. I’ve had many a talk with teachers and principals. And sometimes I just help my girls build a thick skin to combat all the insensitive idiots out there…
Twitter @ aprilabtbalance
This post inspired me to write about family assignments on Parentella: http://blog.parentella.com/2010/families-and-school-in-the-21st-century/
April´s last blog ..10 Reasons my Riley is awesome
Twitter @ soon2bsinglemom
Wow, I really can’t believe this teacher went as far to ask the mom to divulge more information. Clearly, it’s none of the teacher’s business.
What if the parents weren’t divorced and the father was deceased? What if there were two moms? It’s 2010 and teachers (as well as the general public) should realize that the nuclear family of the 50s doesn’t exist. In my situation, my son will always know that his family is mommy and daddy…even if we don’t live in the same house.
A´s last blog ..Missing Out
Twitter @ http://deleted
The teacher is definitely out of line. First off, I don’t agree with her calling the mom to find out why the bio dad wasn’t in the picture in the first place. Families come in all shapes and sizes, and it isn’t the teacher’s buissness or place to call and pry into the lives of others, and about why who and who isn’t in some class assignment. I would be offended, and I would go to that conference to explain that to her.
YES, the teacher is out of bounds! I would go ballistic on her to question my family dynamic. NOT HER PLACE. Her place is to make every student feel good about themselves even if she does not understand or agree with their family dynamic. The fact is that is her family and that is that. I would let this teacher know that real quick. I can’t even believe this took place and is an issue….I mean hello single parents make up a huge percentage of the world today…where in the @$%% is this teacher from….space? I guess she will just loose her mind if a child comes in and draws two daddy’s or two mommy’s. I would tell her welcome to the 20th century…idiot.
Twitter @ officediva1
I want to cuss so bad over this. The mom has told all the info that the teacher needs to know. Teacher sounds nosy to me. But I’m willing to give her the benefit of the doubt if the child has had conversations with her in the classroom that the mom is unaware of. If so, the teacher needs to tell the mom about them. That way mom can give more info about the situation. I am always up front with my child’s teacher about our family (me, daughter, my mom, stepdad, and her father who dipped out before she was born). I never had a teacher ask for more info.
Miss OD1: We’re always grateful for a honest comment. And we appreciate your loyalty to this mom. Thanks SO much for adding to this conversation.
Twitter @ SingleMomWeekly
It is scary to think that such insensitive people are shaping our youth.
Twitter @ singlemombooks
The teacher, if she really wanted ‘details’ could refer to the unending forms that are filled out during enrollment. My strategy is, and always has been, to contact my daughter’s teachers early in the year and give them information about our situation – just enough so they can do their jobs and keep an eye out for any by-products of not having bio-dad around (and what to do when he did contact them). This feels a little like “single mom judgement” to me and mom may want to address this with the school counselor or principal. Needing info is one thing, being nosy and wanting anything additional isn’t really appropriate. Best wishes!
Honoree Corder´s last blog ..Single Moms: Therapy Can Help You and Your Kids
Twitter @ http://myadventures-in-mommyland.blogspot.com/
I’m so surprised by this. Various types of family are normal now (single parenting, children living with grandparents, families with 2 moms or 2 dads, etc.) that I can’t believe the teacher is finding it such a an issue to pry. She is just being nosy and in my opinion very inappropriate. I could understand if it was the school psychologist asking more questions because maybe there was an incident that occurred but I don’t think it’s the teachers place especially since the mother already came in and gave a brief explanation.
Tania´s last blog ..Out of the office